An Exposition, Critical, Doctrinal, and Practical, of the Assembly’s Shorter Catechism (1788), Michael Arthur · PDF

The Divine Decrees

Acts xv. 18.

Known unto God are all his works from the beginning of the world.

A dispute had arisen in the Christian church, which now flourished in the city of Antioch, in relation to the necessity of circumcision. Antioch was the name of two cities mentioned in scripture; the one the capital of Syria; the other of Pisidia. It is of the former I now speak. This is known to have been one of the most flourishing, opulent, trading cities in the world. It stood on both sides of the river Orontes, about twelve miles from the Mediterranean sea; and is said to have been about ten miles in circuit. Of the preaching of the gospel in this great city, and the success that attended it, we have the history in the preceding part of this book. But soon was the tranquillity of this church disturbed. Certain designing men, coming down from Jerusalem with pretended apostolical authority, insisted on the necessity of the continued observation of circumcision. In order that this doubtful point might be determined, and the tranquillity of the Antiochian church restored, it was agreed to dispatch commissioners to Jerusalem, that the Apostles and others in that city might be consulted on the subject. The deputies having arrived at Jerusalem, a convention was immediately called. The cause being fairly stated, and parties fully heard, an unequivocal and plain decision was given. The text, which I have now read, is part of a speech delivered by a venerable member of that synod. The interesting point of the vocation of the Gentiles, in virtue of the abolition of the ceremonial law, which had so long stood, as a wall of separation between the Jews and all other nations, is here ascertained. The apostolical member shows, that every thing which comes to pass in time, in the world, and especially the church, is in pursuance and the fulfilment of designs which the infinite God had in his all-comprehending mind from eternity. For, as saith the text, Known unto God are all his works from the beginning of the world. What works soever, natural or supernatural, providential or gracious, he performs in time, he foreknew and appointed from everlasting.

So speaks our Shorter Catechism in the answer to the question, What are the decrees of God? which is—The decrees of God are his eternal purpose, according to the counsel of his will, whereby, for his own glory, he hath foreordained whatsoever comes to pass. Having considered the being and perfections of God, the unity of the Godhead, and the Trinity of persons in it, I am now, according to the most natural order, led to explain the purposes and designs, which this omniscient Being, from a beginningless eternity, formed in his all-foreseeing mind; and which he executes in his works of creation, providence, and redemption. We are now entering on another abstruse subject. With the utmost caution are we ever to think and speak of it. How imperfect our apprehensions and views of the divine purposes, as well as of the perfections and the persons in the Godhead? Who can pretend to read the annals of eternity? Who can comprehend the designs of Deity? O the depth of the riches both of the wisdom and knowledge of God! How unsearchable are his judgments, and his ways past finding out! For who hath known the mind of the Lord, or who hath been his counsellor? Rom. xi. 33, 34. Does the great God act at random? Does he things without previous designs? Such a supposition is unworthy of God.

Often do we act at random. For our conduct we can assign no proper reason. Our former purposes we alter. New resolutions and measures do we adopt. Does not our behaviour, in all these instances, bespeak imperfection? But, as God is in all respects perfect, his purposes ever must be permanent and unalterable. Now, that he had in his infinite mind from everlasting the whole plan of his conduct from first to last in time, the scripture often and clearly intimates. Is not this the plain purport of a variety of expressions which occur in the scriptures both of the Old Testament and the New? We read of his thoughts, his counsels, his purposes, his decrees, and the like. The counsel of the Lord standeth for ever; the thoughts of his heart to all generations. Psal. xxxiii. 11. My counsel, says he, shall stand, and I will do all my pleasure. Isa. xlvi. 10.

The divine decrees I am, in the sequel, to consider especially in a twofold view; as they relate to the creatures, all the creatures, and all their actions; and as they refer to the rational, in distinction from the inferior, creatures. The former I may call a general, the latter a particular, account of the decrees. In order to give you a general view of the decrees, I may, in a plain manner, consider the several parts of the answer in order. And,

I. The nature of the divine decrees. This is expressed in the answer by two words, purpose, and fore-ordination. For thus the answer runs—The decrees of God are his eternal purpose, according to the counsel of his will, whereby, for his own glory, he hath foreordained whatsoever comes to pass. The design and meaning of both expressions are sufficiently manifest and plain. A critical explanation of them is altogether unnecessary. It is, however, to be observed, that the word is, with an obvious design, put in the singular number, rather than the plural. The answer is not thus—The decrees of God are his eternal purposes; but thus—The decrees of God are his eternal purpose. This purpose, indeed, extends to a vast variety of creatures, and of actions. But in itself it is one simple act of the understanding and the will of God. Infinitely different are his designs and ours. When we project any great undertaking, we form the plan, and concert means for carrying it into execution, in a gradual manner. We have not a full view or idea of it at once. The design, when fully formed, is the result of long deliberation and much thought. Far otherwise is it, however, with the infinite God. His designs are as perfect at once as ever they can be. He cannot possibly be in hesitation or suspense about any thing. Never can he have a fuller knowledge or clearer idea of any thing within the reach of his unbounded power, than he has this moment and ever had. His knowledge is just now what it ever has been. Nor can it undergo any enlargement. It can never be greater than it now is.

The question speaks of decrees in the plural number, and the answer of purpose in the singular. The latter, as I hinted already, may signify that act of the divine will, which foreordained every thing that has, and every thing that is to come to pass throughout all futurity. The former may have been intended to denote the variety of the creatures and of their actions; about all which the decrees of God are versant. Most pertinent and expressive is the word purpose here used by the Compilers of the Catechism. They probably borrowed it from Ephes. i. ii. where the Apostle speaks of the purpose of him who worketh all things after the counsel of his own will. The expression may especially bespeak three things. It may bespeak the sovereignty and perfect freedom with which the great God ever acts. It may indicate the most consummate wisdom and deep design. And it shows the permanency and stability of his designs.

The great God ever is his own director; and designs and performs whatsoever he pleaseth without control. One thing he performs; another, equally within the compass of his unlimited power, he does not. The reason is obvious. It pleased him from eternity to purpose within himself to do the one and not the other. For, as the Babylonian monarch speaks—He does according to his will in the army of heaven, and among the inhabitants of the earth; and none can stay his hand, or say unto him, What dost thou? Dan. iv. 35. Far are the purposes of the great God from being rash or hasty. For deliberation, indeed, he has no occasion. But his designs are all as wisely and well concerted as they could possibly have been. Foolish and rash projects and schemes do we often form. But his designs all are the result of unerring wisdom. Infallibly certain is the accomplishment of his designs. Delayed it may be; but obstructed it cannot possibly be. There are many devices in a man’s heart, which he is unable to accomplish; nevertheless, the counsel of the Lord that shall stand. Prov. xix. 21. There is

II. The date of the divine decrees. They are eternal. They are no less ancient and beginningless than God himself. Our schemes and designs are formed in time. We ourselves began to exist in time. But as God himself is without beginning, so are all his purposes and decrees. Conformably to the scriptures, and in opposition to Arminians and others, it is here affirmed, that his purposes are absolute and eternal. It has been pretended, that the divine decrees, especially as they relate to man, were from eternity, in a great part, indeterminate, and suspended upon his good or bad conduct in time. That the righteous are to be, in a gracious manner, rewarded for ever for their good works on earth, and the wicked justly punished for their sins, is certain. But was not every thing relating both to good and bad men, to their conduct in this world, and to their state in that which is to come, known to God from the beginningless ages of eternity? That every thing which has happened, and every thing which is to happen, was known to him from everlasting, may be infallibly inferred from the perfection of his infinite nature, and is, in the most express terms, declared in the sacred scriptures. No farther need I go for a proof of his universal prescience, and preordination of all things from eternity, than the text which is prefixed to this Lecture. For thus it speaks—Known unto God were all his works from the beginning; from the commencement of time, even from the unbeginning ages of eternity.

That the word beginning in the scriptures is sometimes equivalent to eternity, as prior to time, I might show in several instances. One may suffice. I was, says our divine Redeemer, set up from everlasting, from the beginning, ere ever the earth was. Prov. viii. 23. To the most unlearned and superficial reader, it must be obvious, that the terms everlasting and from the beginning, are here used as synonimous. That God from all eternity foreknew and foreordained whatsoever comes to pass in time, is evident from the nature of things as well as the express declarations of the word. Whence is it that such and such things come to pass in time? Is it because such things come within the compass of the Almighty power of God? This certainly cannot be the reason; for many other things equally within the compass of the divine power never do come to pass. Has God in creation, or has he ever in the works of providence, acted according to the full extent of his power? Certainly not. To Almighty power, who can prescribe limits? No boundaries or limits does it know. But the reason why one thing happens, and another thing does not happen, is plain. The one God has, and the other he has not, foreordained to come to pass. This leads me to consider

III. The origin of the divine decrees—The sovereign will of God. To the sovereign and uncontrolable will of God, as the proper spring of all the important designs which he formed in his omniscient mind from everlasting, and all the glorious works which, in pursuance of his eternal purpose, he performs from first to last in time, does an Apostle of the New Testament trace them. For other Christians as well as himself, he speaks thus—Being predestinated according to the purpose of him, who worketh all things after the counsel of his own will. Eph. i. 2.

Might not the great God, had he pleased, have remained for ever alone? As he is self-existent, he is, of consequence, self-sufficient. His design to produce, out of nothing, this great universe, with its numerous and various inhabitants, could not originate in any natural necessity, or in the prospect of any addition to his essential glory and felicity, from the creatures or their actions. It must, therefore, have been an act of his sovereign will, as well as his unerring understanding. And his will can be under no control, but what arises from his sovereignty, wisdom, and other perfections. As he is independent, he can be under no external constraint; and, as he is self-sufficient, he can be under no internal necessity. All his purposes, therefore, must be voluntary. The eternal purpose, however, is said to be according to the counsel of his will. This is intended to show, that, though his will be arbitrary and uncontrolable, he ever acts in a manner the most rational and consummately wise. Self-sufficient and independent, he wills and he works when and what he pleases. Infinitely good and wise, he ever does what is most fit to be done; and does it in the best manner. There is in the

IV. place, The ultimate end of God’s decrees—His own glory. This, as we have seen already, is the principal part of man’s chief end; and it is the chief end of all the creatures and all their actions. It is what God had ultimately in view in all the important and worthy designs which he formed in his great mind from eternity. It is what he ultimately intends in all his works of creation and providence, nature and grace, in time. His motives and views; his designs and dispensations are ever worthy of himself. Such is the supereminent excellency of his nature, that his own glory is the highest end he can possibly propose to himself. And, therefore, as he ever acts with the highest propriety, he ever gives the preference to it. As he is the first cause, he is the last end of all things—For of him, and through him, and to him, are all things; to whom be glory for ever. Amen. Rom. xi. 36. The

V. Article in the division of the answer, is the object of the divine decrees—whatsoever comes to pass. What a vast prospect opens here! The objects of the divine decrees I might consider under two general heads; the creatures, and the actions of the creatures; for to each of the creatures, and to each of their actions, do the divine decrees extend. Here all creation, the mineral, the vegetable, the animal parts of it; unnumbered orders and ranks of creatures; the church, both Jewish and Christian; a long series of interesting events, which have already been accomplished in the world and in the church, to recount which is a work fitter for eternity than time; open to our view. For to all those creatures, and to all these events, do the divine decrees extend; and in them are they executed. The work of creation, the works of providence, the work of redemption, in all their several parts and circumstances, did the all-wise God, by a decree, which nothing can alter, fore-appoint from the earliest ages.

I might consider the divine decrees as they relate to angels; their creation; their station; their employment; and a variety of other things. I might also consider the divine decrees as versant about mankind in this world; the time and other circumstances of their birth; their station and condition; the time and other circumstances of their death. I might consider the divine decrees as they refer to families, to churches, and to nations; to the erection, the duration, the extinction of societies, civil and religious. I might, in a word, consider them as they relate to the creatures, high and low, from the celestial seraph, to the serpent that licks the dust of the earth.

But what I might say in relation to the divine decrees, I shall, for brevity, and to prevent unnecessary repetitions, reserve till I have occasion to consider them as executed in the great work of creation, and especially in the mysterious dispensations of that All-superintending Providence, which extends to all parts of the great universe, and has the disposal of the creatures from the highest to the lowest, and all their actions, good and bad. Though the decree itself ever is understood to precede the execution of it, till it be executed, or otherwise revealed to us, it is to us unknown. And, therefore, the best method we can take to obtain a distinct view of the eternal decrees, is to review the works of time in which they are accomplished.

I might proceed to what I proposed farther on this subject, to consider the decrees as they relate to the eternal state of angels and men.

That branch of the divine decrees, which relates to the everlasting state of angels and of men, is known, in the scriptures, and in theological writings, by the name of Predestination. This word is frequently used in the New Testament. The meaning of it, without any critical or particular explication, is obvious. What, in the general, is intended by it, as applied to angels and men, I cannot express better than in the words of the Larger Catechism, in the answer to the following question.—“What hath God especially decreed concerning angels and men?” “God, by an eternal and immutable decree, out of his mere love, for the praise of his glorious grace, to be manifested in time, hath elected some angels to glory, and, in Christ, hath chosen some men to eternal life, and the means thereof; and also, according to his sovereign power, and the unsearchable counsel of his own will, (whereby he extendeth or withholdeth favour as he pleaseth) hath passed by and foreordained the rest to dishonour and wrath, to be for their sin inflicted, to the praise of the glory of his justice.” This is at once a most consolatory and a most awful subject. With the most profound reverence and caution, are we to enter on the consideration of it.

Long has it been the subject of controversy in the church. In earlier as well as later times has it been impugned and opposed. What opposition was made to it by the ancient Pelagians and Semi-pelagians is well known. The sect of the Pelagians appeared about the end of the fourth or beginning of the fifth century. It is denominated from the founder of it, Pelagius; who is said to have been a native of Britain; but travelled and propagated his errors in Asia and Africa, as well as Europe.

The scriptural doctrine of predestination has been, in later times, corrupted and perverted by Jesuits, Arminians, and others. The Jesuits are well known to be a religious order in the Roman church, founded in the sixteenth century by Ignatius Loyola, a native of Spain. This society evidently borrowed its name from Jesus. It has of late years been abolished with the consent of all the Catholic powers. The Arminians are denominated from their leader, Arminius, a famous minister of Amsterdam. He flourished in the sixteenth century. The instances in which he differed from the Calvinists I need not now enumerate. The great doctrine of predestination is well known to have been one of them.

Predestination, as it relates to both angels and men, consists of two branches generally distinguished by the names of election and reprobation.

I may say a few things on it as it relates to angels. That part of the angels were elected, and part of them passed by, is certain. Of the former the scripture makes express mention. I charge thee, says the Apostle Paul to his son Timothy, before God and the Lord Jesus Christ, and the elect angels, that thou observe these things, without preferring one before another, doing nothing by partiality. 1 Tim. v. 21. Of the non elect, and now fallen angels, two other Apostles make no less express mention. God spared not the angels that sinned, but cast them down to hell, and delivered them into chains of darkness, to be reserved unto judgment. 2 Pet. ii. 4. The angels which kept not their first estate, but left their own habitation, he hath reserved in everlasting chains under darkness, unto the judgment of the great day. Thus the election of a part of the angels is mentioned in the scriptures; and the non-election of others is necessarily implied. Election, as the word literally signifies, denotes the choice of a part out from among the whole. Had all the angels been appointed to be confirmed in their original state of purity and felicity, they might have been said to be predestinated; but could, with no propriety, have been said to be elected. In election a part is pitched upon; others are passed by. Whether the greater part of the angels were chosen, or not chosen, we are not told. The number of the standing, and also of the fallen, is to us unknown. But that the number of both the former and the latter is very great is certain. The design of the election of a great part of the angels is obvious. It was to confirm them in their first estate, and prevent their fall.

It is natural to ask here, whether there be any difference between the election of angels and that of men; and, if there be, in what it consists. That there is a wide difference between the two is evident. It may consist especially in three things.

1st, In election the angels were foreseen and considered as holy and happy beings. They were chosen, as I said already, to be confirmed in a state of holiness and happiness. In election men were foreseen and considered as sinful and fallen creatures.

2dly, The angels are no where said to have been elected in Christ. It has, indeed, been the opinion of great and good men, that, though the angels never sinned, and consequently never needed Christ as a Redeemer, he is to them a confirming head. But sinners of mankind are expressly said to have been elected in Christ. For others as well as himself the Apostle speaks thus—Blessed be the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who hath blessed us with all spiritual blessings in heavenly places in Christ, according as he hath chosen us in him before the foundation of the world. Eph. i. 3, 4.

3dly, Sinners of mankind are said to have been chosen to salvation. Thus the Apostle bespeaks the believing Thessalonians—We are bound to give thanks alway to God for you, brethren, beloved of the Lord, because God hath from the beginning chosen you to salvation, through sanctification of the Spirit, and belief of the truth. 2 Thess. ii. 13. But no where are angels said to have been chosen to salvation. To it they could not be chosen. They never sinned to need a Saviour.

The election of a part of the angels implies the non-election of others. This is usually called Reprobation. According to the definition of it, in the answer which I have quoted from the Larger Catechism, it implies in it two things; preterition and preordination of the objects of it to that punishment which they, in time, incur by their sins. But what I have to say on this tremendous subject, I shall postpone till I consider it in relation to men. I should, therefore, proceed to the great subject of the predestination of mankind, including both the election of a part of them, and the non-election of others. Sublime, mysterious subject! It has been pled that this subject is of such a nature, that to introduce it into the pulpit, and discuss it before a popular audience, is improper, if not dangerous. That it ought to be treated with peculiar caution and delicacy is certain. But that it is a part of the revealed will of God, and that revealed things belong unto us and to our children, who can deny? However, as it is expressly mentioned in the answer to a subsequent question of the Catechism, I have resolved to delay the consideration of it till I come to that place.

Having postponed the solution of several difficulties in relation to the divine decrees, as they refer to the creatures in general, till I have an opportunity to explain the works of providence; and the consideration of the election and non-election of men, till I enter on the elucidation of the answer to the following question—“Did God leave all mankind to perish in the estate of sin and misery?” I shall, for the present, dismiss the subject of the decrees with a few reflections.

How derogatory to the sovereignty, the prescience, the perfection, the immutability of God, is the Socinian notion that the decrees of God are not eternal! Some of them the Socinians can allow to be, in a qualified sense, eternal. Others they will not admit to be in any respect eternal. But that God from eternity infallibly foreknew, and foreappointed every thing which comes to pass in time, may be inferred from the perfection of his nature; and is often intimated to us in the scriptures.

How unworthy of God is the notion of the Pelagians and Semi-pelagians, whether ancient or modern, that many things are decreed in a conditional and uncertain manner! Did not the omniscient Being, from everlasting, foreknow all the circumstances in which his creatures can possibly be placed in time, and how they act severally in these circumstances? Are things past and to come with God as they are with us? Is his knowledge imperfect and progressive as ours is? Can he be in hesitation or suspense about any of his creatures or any of their actions?

The divine decree, foreordaining whatsoever comes to pass, ever must be understood in a consistency with that freedom with which rational and accountable creatures are supposed to act; and with the essential distinction between actions natural and necessary, and actions which are fortuitous and contingent. The fatality or destiny of the ancient Stoics the scripture knows not. The actual futurition and accomplishment of every thing decreed from eternity is, indeed, infallibly certain. It cannot but happen. And that evil actions, no less than good, are determined to be, I am in the sequel, to evince from the scriptures. But the foreappointment of an evil action does not influence or prompt the rational agent to commit it. He acts with as full freedom, as if no such preordination had obtained from eternity. The inclination, the propensity, to evil does not originate in God or his purposes. It originates in the depravation of the sinful person that commits it. God cannot be the author of sin. He, no doubt, permits it, otherwise it could not happen; but he cannot possibly excite to the commission of it.

What hath been said accounts for the futurition of one thing, and the non-futurition of another no less possible, or even likely, than the former. To the eternal decrees, as their proper source, may all the works of time be traced; and into divine sovereignty may the decrees be resolved. How conspicuous is sovereignty in the purposes of God, and in the accomplishment of them! Might not the self-sufficient God, had he pleased, have existed for ever alone? Let us look back into the ages which preceded the commencement of time. We find the infinite God existing alone; and infinitely happy in the fruition of his all-sufficient Self. But we, at the same time, find him in sovereignty purposing within himself to produce a vast variety of other beings. He is the fountain of being and felicity. How delightful an employment for us to travel back beyond the boundaries of time, and the limits of creation; to contemplate the divine Being forming designs for bringing into existence and imparting felicity to millions of millions of other beings; who, had it not been for his sovereignty and benignity, must have lain for ever in the womb of non-entity! Great God, what are the creatures, that thou shouldest, from eternal ages, have concerted measures for bringing them into being, and making them happy! Lord, what is man! As the heavens are high above the earth, so are thy thoughts above our thoughts, and thy ways above our ways.

Is it so? Is every thing that happens in time determined from eternity? Then let us, without repining, submit to our lot on earth. Whether we be in prosperity or in adversity, afflicted or comforted, each of us may adopt Job’s words—He performeth the thing that is appointed, which he himself, from beginningless ages, appointed for me: and many such things are with him. Job xxiii. 14. Often, indeed, have we a sinful hand in procuring evil things to ourselves, and provoking the Lord to withhold good things from us. But, if we be the children of God, he will over-rule all things, the very worst that can possibly befal us, for our good in a subserviency to his glory. We know, on the ground of the faithful promise of God, that all things work together for good to them that love God, to them that are called according to his purpose. Rom. viii. 28.