An Exposition, Critical, Doctrinal, and Practical, of the Assembly’s Shorter Catechism (1788), Michael Arthur · PDF

The Sacred Trinity

1 John v. 7.

For there are Three that bear record in heaven, the Father, the Word, and the Holy Ghost; and these Three are one.

In each period of the church there is one article of truth or another, which, in an especial manner, is controverted. On this account it may be termed, in the apostolic stile, the present truth. 2 Pet. i. 12. The great question in the first ages of Christianity was, whether Jesus of Nazareth was the Son of God, and the Saviour of the world. Accordingly to this important truth the Apostles give their unanimous and most explicit attestations; especially the Apostle John, the longest lived of the Apostles, and the last of all the inspired writers. That Jesus, the Saviour of the world, is the Son of God, not inferior, but equal, to his divine Father, is the cardinal point in Christianity; and, therefore, has numerous and glorious testimonies adduced in proof of it in the scriptures of both the Old and the New Testaments. Here the Apostle probably alludes to the manner in which any thing doubtful was ascertained by the Jewish law. It was established by the concurring testimonies of two or three witnesses. Here we have three concurring witnesses in heaven, and as many on earth. Of three practical witnesses on earth verse 8th speaks. The verse read specifies three personal witnesses in heaven. Here we have the fullest revelation of the mystery of the Trinity; three persons, as such, distinct one from another in one individual Godhead. Having spoken of the being, of the perfections, and of the oneness of God,

I am now led to the consideration of the sublime mystery of the Trinity; which, in the Catechism, is stated thus—There are three persons in the Godhead, the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost; and these three are one God, the same in substance, equal in power and glory. One God, and three distinct persons in one Godhead! I am now, my friends, entering on the consideration of a mystery, which neither seraphic spirits nor glorified saints will undertake to unravel. What then can I say? or what can you expect from me, on such a subject? With the most obvious propriety did the ancient Jews call it the mystery of mysteries. That it is we know; but how it is we know not. No article of supernatural religion, however, is more copiously revealed. That there are three in one, and that there is one in three; three distinct persons in one undivided Godhead; and one undivided Godhead subsisting in three distinct persons; is the uniform declaration of all the sacred writers, from the Prophet Moses to the Apostle John. Hence, though we never can comprehend it, we are indispensibly bound to believe it. It is not our reason, but divine revelation, that is the rule of our faith. In order to pave the way for an explanation of the answer, I am now to suggest to you a few introductory observations relating to this glorious mystery. And,

First, It is an article of supernatural revelation. It is not discoverable by the light of nature. It can be known only by divine revelation. The knowledge which Adam in innocency is supposed to have had of it, lays no foundation for the supposition, that by the light of nature his descendents may discover it. The difference between day and night is not so great as that between the state in which he then was, and that in which they now are. His understanding was a lamp of light. Their understanding is gross darkness. Eph. v. 8. It has, indeed, been pretended, that the mystery of the Trinity was not altogether unknown to the Heathen philosophers, either prior or posterior to the birth of Christ. But even though we were to admit the supposition, that the Heathen philosophers had some indistinct notion or idea of the Trinity, it will not prove that it is discoverable by the light of nature. It is much more reasonable to suppose, that they might learn it from tradition. Some of them might have had intercourse with the Jews, or communication with others who had intercourse with them, and thus might learn it from them. That God, who has the sovereign disposal of all things, best knows his own designs, and has both wisdom and power sufficient to over-rule all providential events in subserviency to the accomplishment of them. Thus matters were so wisely ordered, that, in the ages which immediately preceded the first propagation of Christianity among the nations of the world, the Jews were in great numbers dispersed through all neighbouring countries; and this prepared the way for the introduction of the worship of the true God into places, in which, till then, it had been altogether unknown. Hence, when the Apostles came to any city or country of the Gentile world, they preached first to the Jews; and the first churches consisted partly of Jewish and partly of Gentile converts.

Secondly, The mystery of the Trinity has been an article of the Creed of both Jews and Christians; or, in other words, it has been known and believed in the church of God both under the Old and New Testaments That it is a doctrine of supernatural revelation, and, strictly speaking, known in the church only, we have seen already. Mahometans not only deny it, but treat it with contempt. As an awful token of the degeneracy of the modern Jews, and that they are abandoned of God, they deny it; calling it, in the way of derision, a Christian novelty. But that it is a part of the earlier as well as the later revelations, with which the church has been favoured; or, in other words, that it is revealed in the Old Testament as well as the New, and was believed in the Jewish as it is in the Christian church, I shall endeavour to prove in the sequel. That it was as clearly revealed to the Jews as it now is to Christians, and that they had as distinct views of it as we have, I do not affirm. But I said, and I say again, that in the scriptures of the Old Testament, as well as the New, we have sufficient intimations of a plurality, and even a Trinity, of persons in the one undivided Godhead.

Thirdly, The glorious Trinity is an article, which it is necessary for us all to know and believe. What God has not been pleased to reveal to us, it neither is possible or necessary for us to know. But what he has revealed we are indispensibly bound to know and believe. The secret things belong unto the Lord our God; but those things which are revealed belong unto us, and to our children for ever. Deut. xxix. 29. Among the various articles of revelation, there are certain points which are of capital importance in the Christian system; and which, for this reason, have been designed fundamental articles, or foundation-truths. This mode of speaking seems evidently to be borrowed from Heb. vi. 1. Leaving the principles of the doctrine of Christ, let us go on unto perfection; not laying the foundation, &c. As a builder first lays the foundation, and then raises the superstructure upon it, persons need first to be initiated in the knowledge of the primary articles or fundamental truths of revelation, that they may advance in the study and knowledge of the other parts of it. Now, that the doctrine of the holy Trinity is a fundamental article in revealed religion is manifest. The knowledge of it is indispensibly requisite, in order to a distinct view of the œconomy of redemption. In this important work, each of the divine Three performs his peculiar part, and displays his proper personal glory. Without the knowledge of the mysterious distinction of persons in the undivided Godhead, we cannot possibly have any proper view of the manner in which they concur and act in that great work. It is affirmed, that it is life eternal to know the only true God and Jesus Christ whom he hath sent. John xvii. 3. Is there not here a plain intimation, that the knowledge of the distinction of persons in the Godhead is indispensibly necessary? The great doctrine of the ever-blessed Trinity, in short, is the grand characteristic of the Christian religion. By this it is distinguished and dignified above every religion in the world. The Pagans, as I hinted already, are ignorant of it; Mahometans and modern Jews deny it. It must, therefore, be incumbent upon us, as Christians, to be well instructed and confirmed in it; in opposition to the absurd hypotheses of adversaries of every denomination.

Fourthly, The mysterious nature of the doctrine of the Trinity can be no sufficient reason for our not receiving and believing it. That it is a mystery, and a very great mystery, who can deny? Of the numerous mysteries of our holy religion, it certainly is the chief. Often does the word mystery occur in the scriptures, and in different views may it be understood. It may denote what was altogether unknown in the world till revelation discovered it to the church; or what was at first discovered in an obscurer, and afterwards in a fuller and clearer, manner; or, in fine, a thing of such an abstruse nature, that, after the fullest and clearest revelations that can be made of it to us, it only is a very imperfect, indistinct, and inadequate conception we can form of it. And may not the sacred Trinity, in all these different views, be called a mystery? A mystery it ever has been; and it must continue to be. In heaven as well as on earth, to angels as well as to men, is it a profound mystery. A mystery, no doubt, it is. An absurdity, however, it is not. Human reason it infinitely transcends; but does not contradict. Often have adversaries egregiously misrepresented it; and by their wicked misrepresentations confirmed themselves in their prejudices against it. Did we hold that God is in the same sense one and three, adversaries might well triumph. But when we say that he is in one sense one, and in another three; or that the divine essence is one, and the divine persons three, where is the inconsistency or contradiction? I shall only add,

Fifthly, That the great article of the sacred Trinity has been the subject of much controversy all along, in the earlier as well as the later ages of the Christian church. On the head of the numerous opposers of it, in the earlier ages of Christianity, appears the infamous Simon Magus, of whom, and whose temporary hypocritical profession of the Christian religion, we read in the eighth chapter of the Acts. It is said, that he most impiously pretended to be God; and, in imitation of the Trinity, assumed three different personal characters, in which he appeared and acted in different places. In Samaria he pretended to be God the Father; in Judea God the Son; and in other places God the Holy Ghost. So awfully infatuated were his deluded votaries, that he and his strumpet Helena were the objects of their veneration and worship. His successors, though they differed from him, and from one another, were the most violent opposers and virulent defamers of genuine Christianity; and particularly of the sacred mystery of the Trinity. Their peculiar heresies are known to all versant in the history of the ancient church. To follow them through their manifold labyrinths of contradiction and absurdity could afford but small instruction to a popular audience.

Having premised these preparatory considerations, I proceed to as plain an explanation of the answer, as the nature of the mysterious subject will admit. The

I. Thing in the answer which offers itself to our consideration, is the word Godhead. This is a scripture-expression. Once and again does it occur in the New Testament. For the invisible things of him from the creation of the world are clearly seen, being understood by the things that are made, even his eternal power and GODHEAD. Rom. i. 20.—For in him, that is Christ, dwelleth all the fulness of the GODHEAD bodily. Col. ii. 9. Godhead in the scriptures, and agreeably to them in the answer, evidently denotes that infinite, eternal, and unchangeable nature or essence, which is not peculiar to the Father, or the Son, or the Holy Ghost; but common to all the three; and subsists, though in a different manner, in each of them. Accordingly,

II. It is affirmed, that in this undivided Godhead, there are THREE PERSONS. Personality, and a diversity of persons, the scripture expressly ascribes to the Godhead. Very different, indeed, is personality as applied to God, and as applied to his intelligent creatures. Inattention to the vast disparity between the two has led many into gross errors. Three human persons are three different beings. But the three divine persons are one being. An individual nature, of the created kind, admits of one and but one personality, subsisting in one person only. But the divine nature admits of three different modes of personal subsistence. It subsists in three persons, as persons, distinct one from another. It admits, as we will see in the sequel, of paternity, filiation, procession. Accordingly, to express at once the diversity of divine persons, and the unity of the divine essence, as common to them all, the word Trinity was introduced, at an early period, into the Christian church; and ever since has been continued and used in it. It is not, indeed, in so many letters and syllables, extant in the scriptures. For this reason, adversaries have objected to it. But with what will not cavillers find fault? Is it not a very apposite and happy term to express this profound mystery? It is, as is obvious to all, composed of two words; the one signifying three, and the other one. For by the Trinity we understand three persons in one undivided Godhead; and one undivided Godhead in three persons.

Some have abstracted personality from the Godhead altogether. But this only is one of the numberless instances, in which the great God has been affronted and debased, by his presumptuous creatures, in a manner which it is a shame to mention. Others have held, that as there only is one divine essence, there can be only one divine person. They pretend, that the intimations of a diversity in the Godhead, which so often occur in scripture, must be interpreted not of different persons in it, but of one person sustaining different characters and relations, in which he occasionally appears and acts among his creatures. That one person, in our world, may, and often does, sustain a variety of characters, cannot be denied. He may be, for instance, a father and a son; in relation to one a father, and in respect of another a son. But do not these different characters, of father and son, even among mankind, imply different persons? If the Godhead subsists in one person as a Father, must it not subsist in another as a Son? Can there be a father without a son? or a son without a father?

A third sort have admitted, that there are three divine persons; but they thence infer that there must be three divine Beings. They do not attend to the infinite disproportion between divine persons and human. Two human persons must be two different beings. Though specifically the same, they must be numerically different. But infinitely does the divine Nature transcend all created natures, angelic as well as human. In terms the most express and plain, does the scripture at once affirm the ONENESS of the Godhead, and the mysterious DISTINCTION of persons in it. Nothing can be fuller and plainer than the declaration in the text prefixed to this Lecture. Expressly is the personality of the eternal Father, the first of the divine Three, mentioned in the scriptures. God hath in these last days spoken unto us by his Son; who, being the brightness of his glory, and the express image of HIS PERSON—Heb. i. 3. In a manner no less explicit and plain is personality attributed to the eternal Son, the second of the co-eternal Three. To whom ye forgive any thing, I forgive also: for if I forgave any thing, to whom I forgave it, for your sakes forgave I it in the PERSON of Christ. 2 Cor. ii. 10. The word in the Greek text used here, and applied to the eternal Son, is, indeed, different from that used in Heb. i. 3, and applied to the eternal Father. But the same word is by this inspired writer used elsewhere, and applied to persons. 2 Cor. i. 11. As for the controversies between the Greeks and Latins, or the eastern and western churches, about the proper signification of the Greek word translated person—I am not now to canvass them. The meaning of it among us is established and universally known. The discriminating characters by which the divine Three are at once distinguished, and related to one another, paternity, filiation, and procession, will come to be considered under a following head. The word person, is not, indeed, any where in the scriptures, directly applied to the third subsistence in the Trinity. But as he is every where affirmed to be a different subsistence from the first and the second, and equal to them, it follows, by the most necessary and unavoidable consequence, that he, no less than they, must be, in the most proper sense of the word, a divine person.

The great truth asserted here, that in the undivided Godhead there is a distinction of persons, the scriptures clearly, and in places innumerable, intimate to us. The old Testament contains numerous intimations of it. These intimations are of two kinds; indefinite and indirect; or definite and direct. By the former I understand intimations, that in the Godhead there is a plurality of persons. By the latter I mean intimations, that in the undivided Godhead there is a Trinity of persons; not merely a plurality, but a Trinity.

An intimation of the former kind has been supposed to be couched in the plural word ELOHIM, which we translate God. Thus the very first of all the sacred Books begins with an intimation of this profound mystery. Gen. i. 1. Of it there are understood to be additional intimations in this chapter. For, in verse 2, there is express mention of GOD, and of the SPIRIT of God. And, at verse 26th, the omnipotent Creator is introduced speaking thus—Let US make man in OUR image, after OUR likeness. He has, indeed, been understood to speak in the plural number here, after the manner of the potentates of the earth. According to this hypothesis the plural number bespeaks majesty, rather than a plurality of persons in the Godhead. But, not to mention other things, there is one obvious objection to this interpretation, which the abettors of it never have been able to remove. The fact, that this mode of speaking was used by the great men of the world in those early times, they have ever been unable to ascertain. It has been observed, that this part of the royal stile is of no very great antiquity, even in our own country. In the history of the fall, and the consequences of it, we have a further intimation of a plurality in the Godhead—The Lord God said, Behold, the man is become as one of US, to know good and evil. Gen. iii. 22. On occasion of the introduction of the confusion of languages at the building of Babel, the great God speaks thus—Go to, let US go down, and there confound their language, that they may not understand one another’s speech. Gen. xi. 7. In the account we have of the destruction of Sodom, and the other cities of the plain, it is said—The LORD rained upon Sodom, and upon Gomorrah, brimstone and fire FROM THE LORD out of heaven. Gen. xix. 24. Is not one divine person here said to rain brimstone and fire from another divine person? Is not the former evidently to be understood of the eternal Son, and the latter of the eternal Father? In Psalm xlv. 6. there is express mention of one divine person, stiled God; and in verse 7th, of another divine person, called God and his God. That the former is to be understood of God the Son, our glorious Mediator, and the latter of God the Father, an inspired writer of the New Testament, as an infallible expositor of Old Testament scripture, informs us. Heb. i. 8, 9. To all which I shall only add, Isa. vi. 8. I heard the voice of the Lord, saying, Whom shall I send, and who will go for US?

But in the scriptures we have numerous revelations of a Trinity; not merely of a plurality, but of a Trinity in the one Godhead. Such numerous intimations of this sublime mystery may be intended to intimate to us the great importance of it. The Jewish writers have pretended to find it in the incommunicable and ineffable name JEHOVAH. They have observed, that, though it contains four letters, it has in it only three different letters. In one of the three they find God the Father, in another God the Son, and in the third God the Holy Ghost. And the letter, in which they find the Son, they say is doubled, to signify the mystery of his two natures, the divine and the human. But, however this be, we have in the scriptures of the Old Testament, as well as the New, numerous explicit intimations of a Trinity. Is there not an intimation of it in Gen. xlviii. 15, 16.? Here the venerable Patriarch speaks thus—GOD, before whom my fathers, Isaac and Abraham, did walk, the GOD which fed me all my life long unto this day, the ANGEL which redeemed me from all evil, bless the lads.—May not God in the first member of verse 15th mean God the Father, and in the second God the Holy Ghost? And is not the angel spoken of verse 16th evidently to be understood of God the Son, the Angel of the everlasting covenant? Is there not a plain intimation of it in the form of the sacerdotal blessing under the Old Testament, which answers to the apostolical benediction under the New? Thus it runs—The LORD bless thee, and keep thee; the LORD make his face to shine upon thee, and be gracious unto thee; the LORD lift up his countenance upon thee, and give thee peace. Numb. vi. 24, 25, 26. May not the threefold repetition of the divine name be intended to signify the three divine persons? Is it not intimated also by the threefold exclamation of the seraphim? One cried unto another, and said, HOLY, HOLY, HOLY, is the Lord of hosts. Isa. vi. 3. A Jewish paraphrast, who wrote many years before Christ, treating on this passage of the evangelical prophecy, is said to have interpreted this threefold exclamation as a revelation of the mystery of the Trinity. For thus he expounds it—“Holy is the Father, holy is the Son, holy is the Spirit.” We have a revelation of it also in Isa. lxi. 1. where our divine Redeemer speaks thus—The SPIRIT of the LORD GOD is upon ME, because the LORD hath anointed ME, &c. One divine person is the speaker. He speaks of another divine person, whom he stiles the Spirit; and of a third divine person, whom he calls the Lord God. One proof more I shall adduce from the Old Testament. I will mention the loving-kindnesses of the LORD, and the praises of the LORD, according to all that the LORD hath bestowed upon us. Isa. lxiii. 7. May not the recital of the divine name here, three several times, intimate the three divine subsistences in the all-glorious Godhead? But, even supposing that the first of the sacred Three is intended in this verse, in the sequel of the chapter we have mention of the other two divine persons. The second person, stiled the ANGEL of his presence, is mentioned in the 9th verse; and the third person, called his Holy Spirit, is mentioned in verse 10th.

Have I not now sufficiently evinced what I advanced in the entry on this mysterious subject, that the doctrine of the holy Trinity is a capital part of the revelations which God has all along granted to the church, in the earlier, as well as the later ages of it? and that, therefore, it must have been an article of the creed of Jews, as really as it now is of Christians?

But the revelations of this supernatural mystery, which we have in the New Testament, are still more copious and explicit. Let me select a few of the many glorious testimonies, which it gives to this capital article of revealed religion. I begin with the words of the angel to the virgin-mother—The HOLY GHOST shall come upon thee, and the power of the HIGHEST shall overshadow thee; therefore also, that holy thing which shall be born of thee, shall be called the SON of GOD. We have here the HOLY GHOST, the third person in the order of subsistence; the highest, the first person, whose power the Holy Ghost is said to be, inasmuch as it was by his special agency that the divine power was now exerted in the formation of the humanity of Jesus Christ; and then the second person, called the Son of God. In the history of the baptism of Jesus Christ, it is said—He saw the SPIRIT OF GOD descending like a dove, and lighting upon him. And, lo, a voice from heaven, saying, this is MY beloved SON, in whom I am well pleased. Matth. iii. 16, 17. What a glorious declaration of the mystery of the Trinity is here? Here is the third person descending after the manner, or in the form, of a dove. Here is the second person on whom the third descended. And here is the first person, who, by an audible voice from the excellent glory, gave this high testimony to the incarnate Redeemer. Plainly is the Trinity intimated in John xiv. 26.; in which our divine Redeemer speaks thus—But the Comforter, which is the HOLY GHOST, whom the FATHER will send in MY name, he shall teach you all things, and bring all things to your remembrance. In these words we have all the divine Three; the second person the speaker, and the first and the third, of whom he speaks. The former he stiles the Father, and the latter the Holy Ghost, the Comforter. The same words are repeated almost without variation in chap. xv. 26. A revelation of the mystery of the Trinity no less express and full we have in the Apostle’s words—If the SPIRIT of HIM that raised up JESUS from the dead dwell in you; he that raised up Christ from the dead shall also quicken your mortal bodies, by his Spirit that dwelleth in you. Rom. viii. 2. where we have the Spirit the third person; Him, who by his Spirit raised up Jesus from the dead, the first person; and Christ, who was raised from the dead, the second person.

An enunciation of the sacred Trinity, equally full and clear, occurs in 1 Cor. vi. 11.; in which the Apostle bespeaks the Corinthian converts thus—Ye are washed, ye are sanctified, ye are justified, in the name of the LORD JESUS, and by the SPIRIT of our GOD. Take notice of the Lord Jesus, the second of the sacred Three; of the Spirit, the third; and our God, the first. In chap. xii. of this same epistle, verses 4, 5, 6, the Apostle furnishes us with another enumeration of the sacred Three, no less copious than the former. For thus he speaks—There are diversities of gifts, but the same SPIRIT, the third person. And there are differences of administration, but the same LORD, the second person. And there are diversities of operations, but the same GOD, the first person. I may add the Apostle’s prayer for the believing Thessalonians—GOD himself, even our Father, or the first of the co-eternal Three, and our LORD JESUS CHRIST, the second person, direct our way unto you. And the LORD, the Spirit, the third person, make you to increase and abound in love one towards another—1 Thess. iii. 11, 12. THE LORD, the Spirit, direct your hearts into the love of GOD the Father, and into the patient waiting for CHRIST, his Son and our Saviour. 2 Thess. iii. 5.

With the Apostle of the Gentiles, all the other Apostles coincide on this subject. So does the Apostle Peter. For thus he describes the Christians of the dispersion—Elect according to the foreknowledge of God the Father, through sanctification of the Spirit unto obedience, and sprinkling of the blood of Jesus Christ—. 1. Pet. i. 2. Here we have mention, in the most explicit terms, of the Father, the first person; of the Spirit, the third person; and of Jesus Christ, the second person. On this point the Apostle John is not, in perspicuity and fulness, inferior either to Paul or Peter. In behalf of the Asiatic churches, he prays thus—Grace be unto you and peace from him, which was, and which is, and which is to come, that is God the Father, the first of the sacred Three; and from the seven spirits which are before his throne, or God the Holy Ghost, the third person; and from Jesus Christ, the second. Rev. i. 4, 5. To all which I shall only subjoin the apostolical benediction, and the form of baptism prescribed by the Head of the church to be used in it to the end of the world. The former, in 2 Cor. xiii. 14, is—The grace of our Lord Jesus Christ, the second person; and the love of God, the Father, and the communion of the Holy Ghost, the third person, as distinguished from the first and second, be with you all. The latter, in Matth. xxviii. 19, runs thus—Teach all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost; a plain arrangement of all the three glorious persons, according as they subsist in the mysterious Godhead.

Thus, that there are three distinct persons in the one undivided Godhead, is the constant and uniform doctrine of all the inspired writers. Our faith in this radical, this fundamental article has the fullest warrant, and the firmest foundation. Now that the plurality, the Trinity, of which the scripture so often speaks, must be understood not of different characters sustained by one person, but of different persons, is sufficiently manifest from what I have said already. Do they not sustain peculiar personal characters, not merely different characters, but peculiar personal characters? By these they are distinguished one from another. Are not distinct personal acts attributed to them? How often in the scriptures, do we find the Father and the Son speaking one to another, as well as one of another? The inspired writer of the second Psalm introduces the eternal Father speaking to his co-eternal Son before all worlds thus—Ask of me, and I shall give thee the Heathen for thine inheritance, and the uttermost parts of the earth for thy possession. Does a person ask a thing of himself? or can he, with any propriety, be said to give any thing to himself? How often do we find the eternal Son, the second person, speaking of his eternal Father and co-eternal Spirit as different persons from himself? Thus he bespeaks his disciples—I say not unto you, that I will pray the Father. John xvi. 26. Does any person call himself his own father? Can he possibly be his own father? Does any person pray to himself? The Father is expressly said to send the Son to purchase redemption for sinners of mankind; and the Father and the Son to send the Spirit to apply it to them. Of the Father’s sending him, the Son often speaks. Of the Father and the Son sending the Spirit, the Son himself also informs us. John xiv. 26. and xvi. 7. Now, can the same person be at once the sender and the sent? Is a person ever said to send himself?

There is to be observed here the mysterious order in which the divine persons subsist. In respect of it, one is the first; another the second; and another the third. To this order of subsistence, the order in which they act, both in the works of nature and grace, ever corresponds. Never is the Son said to send, or to work by the Father; or the Spirit, to send or work either by the Father or the Son. The Father, on the contrary, is said to send and to work by the Son; and the Father and the Son to send, and to act by the Spirit. By the Son, the Father is affirmed to have made the worlds. Heb. i. 2. By his Spirit, he is said to have garnished the heavens. Job xxvi. 13. It does not at all befit the order of subsistence for the Son, on any occasion, to work by the Father; or for the Spirit to send or work by the Father or the Son.

But, when I speak of an order in which the divine Three subsist, I do not mean that one is, in duration or in dignity, superior and another inferior. As they are all in essence one, they are, as persons, equal one to another. Their essential Oneness, and their personal equality, the scripture most expressly affirms. I and my Father, says our Lord, are one. John x. 30. The equality of the Son to the Father, an Apostle of the New Testament expressly asserts. Phil. ii. 6. I am now,

III. To consider the particular personal characters by which the three divine subsistences, in the one individual Godhead, are distinguished one from another; and most intimately related one to another. I call them personal properties or characters, to distinguish them from the essential perfections or attributes of Deity. Perfections of the latter kind belong to all the divine Three in common. They pertain to that infinite Godhead, which is not peculiar to any one of the three, but common to them all. Properties of the former kind, on the contrary, belong to them as persons; one personal property to one; and another to another of them. Paternity is peculiar to the first; filiation to the second; and procession to the third. The first person neither is begotten nor proceeds, but begets. The second person neither begets nor proceeds, but is begotten. The third person neither begets nor is begotten, but proceeds. Of the first person, as a Father, begetting the second as a Son, we read in Psal. ii. 7. I will declare the decree: The Lord hath said unto me, thou art my Son; this day have I BEGOTTEN thee. Regenerated persons are, indeed, said to be begotten and born of God. Jam. i. 18. 1 John. iii. 9. But infinitely does the eternal generation of the second person of the Trinity, as the Son of God, transcend every other kind of generation. Accordingly, he is stiled God’s only begotten Son. John i. 18. Of the procession of the third person from the first, our Lord speaks expressly in John xv. 26. When the Comforter is come, whom I will send unto you from the Father, even the Spirit of truth, which PROCEEDETH from the Father, he shall testify of me. Though the Spirit is not expressly said to proceed from the Son, as he, in the mysterious order of subsistence, is the intermediate person, the Spirit is understood to proceed from him no less than from the Father. His procession from the Son, as well as the Father, has also been supposed to be intimated to us, when in the scriptures he is stiled the Spirit of the Son, as well as of the Father. Gal. iv. 6. Because ye are sons, God hath sent forth the SPIRIT of his SON into your hearts, crying Abba, Father. This point long divided the eastern and the western churches. The former held, that the Spirit proceeds from the Father only; the latter, that he proceeds from the Father and the Son. In the enumeration of the sacred Three in the text which introduces this Lecture, the second person is, in the usual stile of the Apostle John, denominated the Word. But even in that text the first person is expressly called the Father; and the paternal character of the first person must ever imply the filial character of the second. For there can no more be a father without a son, than a son without a father. The nature of this eternal generation of the Son of God, no creature can pretend to unfold or explain. Far is human generation from being the proper criterion or standard of divine. Never is the one to be accommodated to the other. From such a sublime subject, all carnal, gross conceptions and ideas must ever be banished.

The procession of the Spirit is no less mysterious and inexplicable than the generation of the Son. Neither is it necessary for us to enquire or to know, in what the generation of the one and the procession of the other differ. Differ, however, they must. No where is the Father said to be begotten or to proceed. No where is the Son said either to beget or to proceed. No where is the Spirit said to beget or to be begotten. Do not these different characters manifestly demonstrate two things?

First, That they are, in fact, different persons. Must not the person that begets be different from the person begotten by him? Must not the person that proceeds from the Father and the Son be different from both?

Secondly, That they are necessarily and intimately related one to another. Vain is it to plead, that the Son who is begotten depends upon the Father by whom he is begotten. For the first could no more be without the second, than the second could be without the first. No more, as I said already, can a father be without a son, than a son without a father. Infinitely near and dear are they one to another. Near and dear are a human father and a son. But infinitely nearer and dearer are the eternal Father and his co-eternal Son. The Father and the Son could no more be without the Spirit proceeding from them, than the Spirit could be without the Father and the Son.

All these modes of personal subsistence in the undivided Godhead are no less natural and necessary than the Godhead itself. Is it any wonder that the eternal generation of the Son, and the eternal procession of the Spirit, are to us unknown? The wisest of men, even in his old age, after all the improvements in knowledge which he had made, did not pretend to understand the manner and progress of human generation. Eccl. xi. 5. Far less can any man on earth pretend to explain the eternal generation of the Son of God. All that I need to say on this mysterious and sublime subject, for preventing mistakes, may be comprised in the following hints.

When I say that the first person begets the second, and that the third proceeds from the first and the second, I do not mean that the first divine person existed prior to the second, or that either the first or the second existed prior to the third. A human father necessarily exists prior to his son; but between human and divine generation, there is an infinite, an incomprehensible, disparity.

When we say that the Father, in the mysterious order of subsistence, is the first person, the Son the second, and the Spirit the third, we do not mean that the second is inferior in dignity to the first, or the third to the first or the second. That there is such a mysterious order in which they subsist is manifest. But the second person is equal, not inferior, but equal, to the first; and the third not inferior, but equal to the first and the second.

Moreover, the paternity, the filiation, and the procession, by which the three divine subsistences are known and distinguished, are not essential, but personal acts. It is not in point of essence that the Father is said to beget the Son, the Son is said to be begotten of the Father, or the Spirit is said to proceed from the Father and the Son. The essence is one; and belongs to all the three necessarily, originally, and equally.

I must add, that all these different modes of personal subsistence in the Godhead, and intrinsic relations among the co-eternal Three, are natural and necessary—as natural and necessary as the Godhead itself. It never did, it never can exist without all these different modes of personal subsistence. An individual human nature can subsist in one person only. The divine nature no less necessarily subsists in three persons. Can the former admit of only one personality? The latter, no less requires three different modes of personal subsistence. It originally and necessarily subsists in the first person as a Father. It no less naturally and necessarily subsists in the second as a Son. And it no less originally and necessarily subsists in the third person as proceeding from both. Thus, I say, the different modes of personal subsistence, of which the divine nature admits, and the intrinsic relations in which the co-eternal Three stand to one another, are as natural and necessary as the divine nature itself.

Admirably is this mysterious order, in which the divine Three subsist, exemplified and illustrated by the different parts which they perform in the œconomy of our redemption. The contrivance of the great plan is, in a peculiar manner, attributed to the Father; and the execution of it to the Son and the Spirit; the impetration of it to the Son, and the application to the Spirit. In this work especially have they an opportunity of displaying their personal as well as their essential glory. This probably has led some theological writers of eminence, in other instances agreed with the orthodox, to consider the paternal character of the first person, the filial of the second, and the procession of the third, as œconomical or official, rather than proper personal characters. Such writers, though they hold the Trinity of persons in the undivided Godhead, apprehend that the characters Father, Son, and Spirit, are not original, natural, and necessary to the sacred Three, but rather result from the œconomy of redemption. Their meaning, in short, is this—That there are naturally and necessarily three persons in the Godhead; but, had it not been for the œconomy of grace, they never would have been known to us by such characters and names. One obvious objection, among others, to this opinion is the following. It only is by the different personal characters which the co-eternal Three have assumed, and by which they are revealed to us, that we know that they are different persons. If, therefore, we resign the common personal properties, one of two things must follow. Either we must find other characters by which we are to distinguish them, or resign this fundamental article of the Trinity altogether. If the co-eternal Three were not, as persons, originally distinguished by paternity, filiation, and procession; if these be not the personal characters by which they were originally, independent of the œconomy of redemption, distinguished from one another, what are the different personal characters which belong to them as different subsistences in the Godhead, and by which they were originally distinguished one from another? I shall proceed to the

IV. Thing in the answer. It is affirmed, that these three persons are ONE GOD. Each of them is God. Must there not be then three Gods? No. It only is in respect of their different personalities that they are three. In Godhead they are ONE. Not only does Deity belong to each of them; but one individual Godhead belongs to them all in common. Two things are here asserted—That each of them is God—and that they all are one God. That the Father is God, is admitted on all hands. That the Son, no less than the Father, is God; and that the Spirit, no less than the Father and the Son, is God, the Compilers of the Catechism here affirm. Accordingly, in proof of the Deity of the second and third persons, I shall adduce a number of the many testimonies with which the scriptures of both Testaments amply furnish us.

I begin, first, with the Deity of the Son, the second person. This is an article of capital importance in the Christian system. At an early period of the Christian church, however, was it controverted and denied. The sect of the ancient Arians are well known in ecclesiastical history. They are denominated from Arius a presbyter of Alexandria. He broached his errors in the beginning of the fourth century. What he held in the general was—That the Son had a beginning, and is a creature, though in antiquity and excellency superior to all other creatures. The modern sect of Socinians have gone a step farther than the ancient Arians. They are denominated from Faustus Socinus, a native of Italy. They hold, that the second person had no existence till he was formed in the womb of the Virgin. But, in opposition to adversaries earlier and later, it is here affirmed, that the second person, equally with the first, is God—in personality equal to the Father, and in Godhead one with him.

Now that the Son, no less than the Father, is God, I might evince by a great variety of arguments. In the

First place, The same divine names, which on one occasion are applied to the Father, are, on another, in terms no less explicit, ascribed to the Son. How do we know that the FATHER is God? He is in express terms, and in a sense infinitely too high for any of the creatures, affirmed to be God. In terms equally express, and in a sense equally high, is the SON said to be God. In places almost innumerable is the latter affirmed to be God. To show that the title God, when applied to the Son, is to be understood in the very highest sense, epithets are prefixed to it, which are utterly inapplicable to the most exalted creature in heaven, as well as on earth. He is stiled The MIGHTY GOD. Isa. ix. 6. The Supreme God, or GOD OVER ALL. Rom. ix. 5. The GREAT GOD. Tit. ii. 13. An Apostle tells us, that being in the form of God, he thought it not robbery to be EQUAL with God. Phil. ii. 6. He who, to the astonishment of heaven as well as of earth, voluntarily took upon him the form of a servant, as verse 7th speaks, was originally in the form of God. What is it to be in the form of a servant, but, in fact, to be a servant? What then can it be to be in the form of God, but to be truly God? Irrefragably to prove the Deity of the Son, the scripture applies to him, no less than to the Father, the incommunicable name JEHOVAH. In order to evade the force of this argument, adversaries have alledged, that this name, though called incommunicable, is in the scriptures applied both to persons and things of the created kind. In support of this allegation, they remind us of several inscriptions and titles extant in the Old Testament. Such was the name given to the place in which Abraham sacrificed—Abraham called the name of that place JEHOVAH-JIREH, the Lord will provide. Gen. xxii. 14. Such was the inscription on the altar which Moses built—Moses built an altar, and called the name of it JEHOVAH-NISSI, the Lord is my banner. Exod. xvii. 15. Such also was the name of the altar which Gideon erected—Gideon built an altar there unto the Lord, and called it JEHOVAH-SHALOM, the Lord will perfect. Judg. vi. 24. Such, in a word, is the name of the spiritual city, or New Testament church—The name of the city, from that day, shall be JEHOVAH-SHAMMA, the Lord is there. Ezek. xlviii. 35. But, to every unprejudiced person, it must be sufficiently manifest, that the application of this ineffable name to such places and altars, was only intended to intimate, that He, who was worshipped in those places, and at those altars, was that self-existent, all-sufficient, and independent God, to whom alone the ineffable name Jehovah belongs. It was not properly to the altars or places themselves, but to Him who appeared and was worshipped in them, that the incommunicable name was given.

I shall only take notice of another place, on which the adversaries of our Lord’s divinity have laid no small stress. In order to invalidate the argument which we take from the application of the ineffable name to him, they affirm, that it is applied to the church as expressly as to him, in Jer. xxxiii. 16. In those days shall Judah be saved, and Jerusalem shall dwell safely; and this is the name wherewith She shall be called, JEHOVAH-TZIDKENU, the Lord our righteousness. But, to every impartial reader, it must be apparent, that the passage now quoted is exactly parallel to chap. xxiii. 6. which reads thus—In his days Judah shall be saved, and Israel shall dwell safely; and this is his name wherewith He shall be called, JEHOVAH-TZIDKENU. Any shadow of ground there is for the supposition or the pretence, that in chap. xxxiii. 16. the ineffable name is applied to the church, seems to be owing to a mis-translation. The words might, and probably ought to be, translated otherwise; either thus—This is his name who shall call her, that is the church; or thus—This is the name whereby she shall call him, Jehovah our righteousness. Thus Jehovah appears to be the incommunicable name of God. Now, that this great name, of which God only is worthy, is applied to the Son as well as to the Father, is so manifest, that adversaries themselves are constrained to admit it. So it is in Isa. xl. 3. The voice of him that crieth in the wilderness, Prepare ye the way of JEHOVAH. That the Son, our glorious Mediator, is here intended by Jehovah, is infallibly certain, from the application of this passage to him in the New Testament. Matth. iii. 3. It is so in Isa. viii. 13. Sanctify Jehovah-Tzebaoth, the Lord of hosts; and let him be your fear, and let him be your dread. And he shall be for a sanctuary; and for a stone of stumbling, and for a rock of offence, &c. That these words must be interpreted and understood of God the Son, our glorious Mediator, an inspired writer of the New Testament shows. 1 Pet. ii. 6, 8. To the Son the incommunicable name is applied in Numb. xxi. 6, 7. JEHOVAH sent fiery serpents among the people. Therefore the people came to Moses, and said, We have sinned, for we have spoken against JEHOVAH, and against thee; pray unto JEHOVAH—That the Son is intended here, an Apostle of the New Testament affirms. 1 Cor. x. 9. Once more, in Isa. xlv. 23, 24. I have sworn by myself, the word is gone out of my mouth in righteousness, and shall not return, That unto me every knee shall bow, every tongue shall swear. Surely shall one say, in Jehovah have I righteousness and strength. In interpreting these words of the Son of God, and Saviour of the world, we have an inspired Apostle for our director and pattern. Rom. xiv. 10, 11, 12.

Thus our adorable Saviour is the self-existent, the independent, the everlasting God. Hence, in the

Second place, Divine attributes, as well as divine appellations, are, in the scriptures, ascribed to the Son no less than to the Father. That perfections which belong to no creature in heaven or on earth, but are peculiar to the infinite God, in contradistinction to all other beings, are, in the scriptures, attributed to the Son no less than the Father, I might show in a great multiplicity of instances. Eternity, unbeginning as well as unending eternity, belongs and is ascribed to him. Thus he speaks—I was set up from EVERLASTING, from the beginning, ere ever the earth was. When there were no depths I was brought forth; when there were no fountains abounding with water. Before the mountains were settled; before the hills was I brought forth. While as yet he had not made the earth, nor the fields, nor the highest part of the dust of the world. Prov. viii. 23,—26. What a magnificent description of an unbeginning eternity! Accordingly, he is stiled the Everlasting Father; or, as the phrase is, the Father of eternity. His goings forth have been from of old, from everlasting. Mic. v. 2. I am, says he, ALPHA and OMEGA, the beginning and the ending; which is, and which was, and which is to come—He is the first, as well as the last. Rev. i. 8, 11, 17. Immensity, as well as eternity, is ascribed to him. Is not this necessarily implied in his own words—WHEREEVER two or three are gathered together in my name, there am I in the midst of them. Matth. xviii. 20. And, in chap. xxviii. 20. he bespeaks his Apostles and other ministers in all ages and places of the world thus—Lo, I am with you alway, even unto the end of the world. When he was on earth, in respect of his humanity, in relation to his divinity, he was in heaven as well as upon earth. This is the manifest import of his own words in John iii. 13. Omniscience, no less than immensity, belongs to him—Jesus did not commit himself unto them, because he KNEW all men; and needed not that any should testify of man: for he KNEW what was in man. John ii. 24, 25. Now are we sure, say the disciples, that thou KNOWEST ALL THINGS, and needest not that any man should ask thee. By this we believe that thou camest forth from God. chap. xvi. 30. Peter said unto him, Lord, thou KNOWEST ALL THINGS, thou knowest that I love thee. John xxi. 17. And, says he himself to the Angel of the church in Thyatira, I will kill her children with death; and all the churches shall know that I am he which searcheth the reins and hearts: and I will give unto every one of you according to your works. Rev. ii. 23. Omnipotence, as well as omniscience, is attributed to him. Having said, as in Rev. i. 8. quoted already, I am he which is, and which was, and which is to come; he adds, I am the ALMIGHTY. Immutability, no less than omnipotence, belongs to him. The heavens and the earth shall perish, but thou shalt ENDURE; yea, all of them shall wax old like a garment: but thou art the SAME, and thy years shall have no end. Psal. cii. 25, 26, 27. That these words are to be interpreted of the Son of God, the inspired writer to the Hebrews shows in chap. i. 10, 11, 12. He is the SAME yesterday, and to day, and for ever. chap. xiii. 7. In the

Third place, Divine operations, as well as divine attributes, are, in the scriptures, ascribed to the Son no less than to the Father. There are three kinds of works peculiar to God, or which he only can accomplish; which the scripture uniformly ascribes to the Son, equally with the Father. There is the creation of the heavens and the earth. Now, that the production of all things out of nothing is a work which Almighty God alone could accomplish, the nature of the work itself evinces. And scripture, as well as reason, declares it. Is it not necessarily implied in Isa. xliv. 24? Thus he himself speaks—I am JEHOVAH that maketh all things, that stretched forth the heavens alone. In this great work he had no assistant. He only existed previous to it. If, therefore, this work was effected by the Son, he must be God. That it was his work, no less than the Father’s, the scripture often and loudly proclaims. He himself tells us, that when the Father prepared the heavens, HE was there. Prov. viii. 27. Was he there only as a spectator of the great and glorious work? No. He was there as a co-worker with the Father. For all things were made by him, and without him was not any thing made that was made. John i. 3. By HIM were all things created that are in heaven, and that are on earth, visible and invisible; whether they be thrones, or dominions, or principalities, or powers: all things were created by him and for him. Col. i. 16. The preservation of the great universe is his work no less than the Father’s. As he was a co-worker with the Father in creation, he still is so in the works of providence. So he declares—My Father worketh hitherto, and I work. John v. 17. As he was before all worlds, and created them; by him all things still consist. Col. i. 17. He upholds all things by the word of his power. Heb. i. 2.

The extraordinary works of providence, as well as the ordinary, the scripture ascribes to the Son. Such works, indeed, the Prophets and Apostles accomplished; but in a very different manner. In his name and by his power, did they perform such works. This an Apostle avows in the presence of the Jewish rulers—Be it known unto you all, and unto all the people of Israel, that by the name of JESUS CHRIST of Nazareth, whom ye crucified, whom God raised from the dead, even by him, and by his power, doth this man stand before you whole. Acts iv. 10. Eneas the paralytic the Apostle addresseth thus—Eneas, JESUS CHRIST maketh thee whole. Acts ix. 34. But when the Saviour himself performed miracles, it was in his own name, and by the exertion of power inherent in him as the proper subject of it. In him resided, and from him proceeded, the power, the virtue, by which they were accomplished. Luke vi. 19. and viii. 46.

Gracious, as well as providential, works, which the omnipotent God only can do, the scripture, in instances innumerable and obvious to all, attributes to the Son. Of all the divine works known to us, the redemption of the church, the salvation of sinners of mankind, is the most arduous. In it Almighty power is most illustriously displayed. This is, in a peculiar manner, the work of the Son of God, the Saviour of the world. Is it not the proper act of God to forgive sin? Did not the scribes, in so far, say right? Who can forgive sins but God only? Mark ii. 7. Is it not the peculiar work of God to quicken the dead? God, and God only, quickeneth the dead, and calleth the things which be not as though they were. Rom. iv. 18. The Son, equally with the Father, forgiveth sin, and quickens both spiritually and naturally dead sinners. Him hath God exalted with his right hand to be a Sovereign as well as a Saviour, to grant both repentance to impenitent sinners, and the pardon of all their sins. Acts v. 31. Thus he himself speaks—Verily, verily, I say unto you, The hour is coming, and now is, when the dead shall hear the voice of the Son of God; and they that hear shall live. Marvel not at this; for the hour is coming in the which all that are in their graves shall hear his voice, and shall come forth. John v. 25, 28. In the

Fourth place, Divine worship, as well as divine works, the scriptures ascribe to the Son as well as the Father. That religious worship belongs to God alone is a dictate of reason, as well as a doctrine of revelation. To himself, to the exclusion of all creatures in heaven and on earth, the great God claims and appropriates it. I am JEHOVAH, that is my name; and my glory will I not give to another, neither my praise to graven images. Isa. xlii. 8. To the Son, no less than to the Father, is it every where ascribed. In heaven and on earth, to angels and to men, is he the object of religious adoration. Internal worship, as well as external, do the scriptures attribute to him. He is the object of saving faith. So he speaks of himself—Let not your hearts be troubled, ye believe in God, believe also in ME. Often has it been observed, that both clauses may be read one way; either indicatively, thus—Ye believe in God, and ye believe also in me; or imperatively, thus—Believe ye in God, believe also in me. He is the object of supreme love, as well as of saving faith. This, no doubt, is implied in the trying question, with which he, three several times, poseth Peter—Jesus saith to Simon Peter, Simon, son of Jonas, lovest thou ME more than these? John xxi. 15, 16, 17. Even when he was in a state of the deepest humiliation in our world, as he was God as well as man, he was the object of religious worship, the worship of angels as well as of men. When Jesus was born in Bethlehem of Judea, in the days of Herod the king, behold, there came wise men from the east to Jerusalem, saying, Where is he that is born king of the Jews, for we have seen his star in the east, and are come to worship him. Matth. ii. 1, 2. When he bringeth in the first begotten into the world, he saith, And let all the angels of God worship him. Heb. i. 6. The call is—Kiss the Son. Psal. ii. 12. A kiss sometimes was a sign of religious veneration. Let the men that sacrifice kiss the calves. Heb. xiii. 2. The Son no less than the Father, is the object of prayer. They stoned Stephen calling upon God, and saying, Lord Jesus, receive my spirit. Acts vii. 59. To say no more, the solemn ordinance of baptism is administered in his name, as well as in the name of the Father and of the Spirit. The prescribed form, from which his ministering servants never are to depart, is this—Baptize them in the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost. Matth. xxviii. 19. In the

Fifth place, As an additional proof, and a decisive evidence, that the Son, no less than the Father, is the supreme God, he is, in terms the most express, affirmed to be equal; not inferior, but equal to the Father. To obviate mistakes, and to set this argument in its proper light, it is to be observed, that there is a twofold consideration of the Son. If he is viewed in the character of Mediator, he appears inferior to the Father. As Mediator, he sustains the character of the Father’s servant, and acts in virtue of a commission from him. This accounts for his declaration—My Father is greater than I. John xiv. 28.

But, if we view him in his original personal character, as the second subsistence in the undivided Trinity, he appears in no respect inferior, but, in all respects, equal to his divine Father. Even when, in respect of his humanity, he was found in fashion as a man, and made himself of no reputation, in respect of his divinity, he was still in the form of God, and thought it no robbery to be equal with God. Phil. ii. 6, 7, 8. His eternal Father himself acknowledges him in the high character of his fellow and equal. Zech. xiii. 7. Let Arians and Socinians blush and be ashamed. A creature equal to God! What an absurdity! To all which I may add, in the

Sixth place, That, as the highest demonstration of the supreme Deity of the Son of God, he is affirmed to be not merely equal to the Father, but one with him. So speaks the text that introduces this Lecture. There are Three that bear record in heaven, the Father, the Word, and the Holy Ghost; and these Three are one. As persons the co-eternal Three are equal; and in Deity they are one. One numerical Godhead is common to them all. With this express declaration of the Apostle, the testimony of our Lord himself to this great truth exactly coincides. I and my Father, says he, are one. John x. 30. Having, I hope to the satisfaction of every unprejudiced person, demonstrated that the Son, no less than the Father, is God, I proceed,

Secondly, To make it appear, that the Holy Ghost, as really as the Father and the Son, is the supreme God. The same arguments which prove the supreme Deity of the Son, evince, with equal force, the divinity of the Holy Spirit. Having stated and illustrated them largely, in proof of the former, it must be unnecessary for me to enlarge upon them in proof of the latter. Let me, therefore, resume them as briefly as possible. And in the

1st place, Divine names are, in the scriptures, attributed to the Spirit equally with the Father and the Son; and, therefore, the Spirit, no less than the Father or the Son, must be God. The title God, in the most proper acceptation of the word, is oftener than once directly applied to him. He, who, in Acts v. 3, is stiled the Holy Ghost, is, in the following verse, expressly called God. But this is not all. The ineffable name Jehovah, which, as we have shown already, is peculiar to the great God, in contradistinction to all created beings, is expressly ascribed to him in Isa. vi. 8. I heard the voice of Jehovah, saying, Whom shall I send? and who will go for us? Then said I, here am I, send me. And he said, verse 9th, Go and tell this people, hear ye indeed, but understand not.—Is it asked, How does it appear, that the Holy Ghost, the third of the sacred Three, is intended here? An apostolical interpreter determines the point; for thus he speaks—Well spake the Holy Ghost by Esaias the Prophet, unto our fathers, saying, Go unto this people, and say, Hearing ye shall hear, and shall not understand—Acts xxviii. 25, 26. In the

2d place, Divine perfections, are, in the scriptures, predicated of the Spirit equally with the Father and the Son. His eternity is necessarily supposed and implied in the Mosaic account of the heavens and the earth. Gen. i. 2. His immensity is most elegantly described by the Psalmist—Whither shall I go from thy Spirit? or whither shall I flee from thy presence? If I ascend up into heaven, thou art there; and if I make my bed in hell, behold, thou art there! Psal. cxxxix. 7, 8. His omniscience is evidently implied in our Lord’s words to the disciples—He shall teach you all things. John xiv. 26. And in the words of the Apostle—God hath revealed them unto us by his Spirit; for the Spirit searcheth all things, yea, the deep things of God—The things of God knoweth no man, but the Spirit of God. 1 Cor. ii. 10, 11. Omnipotence, as well as omniscience, belongs to the Spirit equally with the Father and the Son. May he not for this reason be stiled the power of the highest? In the

3d place, Works peculiar to God are attributed to the Spirit equally with the Father and the Son. The creation of all worlds was the work of the third person, no less than of the first and second. By the word of the Lord were the heavens made: and all the host of them by the breath of his mouth, or by his Spirit. Psal. xxxiii. 6. By his Spirit he hath garnished the heavens. Job xxvi. 13. The preservation of all things is the work of the Spirit, as much as of the Father and the Son. Thou sendest forth thy Spirit, they are created, and thou renewest the face of the earth. Psal. civ. 30. Works of the miraculous kind are accomplished by the Spirit. If I cast out devils by the Spirit of God, then the kingdom of God is come unto you. Matth. xii. 28. Redemption, the most arduous, as well as important, of all works, is effected by the Spirit, no less than by the Father and the Son. The applicatory part of it is peculiarly ascribed to the third person. Not by works of righteousness which we have done, but according to his mercy he saved us by the washing of regeneration, and renewing of the Holy Ghost. Tit. iii. 5. The supernatural work of the regeneration of sinners is performed by the special agency of the Holy Ghost. Thus saith the Lord—I will put my Spirit within you, thus will I cause you to walk in my statutes. Ezek. xxxvi. 27. The justification of guilty sinners is attributed to the Spirit, as well as the Father and the Son. Ye are justified in the name of the Lord Jesus, and by the Spirit of our God. 1 Cor. vi. 11. The saving illumination of the minds of sinners in spiritual darkness, is the special work of the Spirit. For this reason is he stiled the Spirit of wisdom and revelation in the knowledge of Christ; and by him the eyes of their understandings are supernaturally enlightened. Eph. i. 17, 18. The great and good work of the sanctification of unholy sinners is, in an especial manner, ascribed to the Spirit. The Apostle bespeaks the believing Thessalonians thus—God hath from the beginning chosen you to salvation, through sanctification of the Spirit. 2 Thess. ii. 13. To add no more on this particular, the glorious work of the resurrection of the dead in Christ is to be effected by the special agency of the Holy Ghost. Hence the Apostle’s consolatory words to the believing Romans—If the Spirit of Him that raised up Jesus from the dead dwell in you; he that raised up Christ from the dead shall also quicken your mortal bodies by his Spirit that dwelleth in you. Rom. viii. 11. Such are the great and glorious works, especially of the saving kind, which this blessed agent performs. Are not these glorious works worthy of God, and calculated to reflect the highest honour upon him? In the

4th place, Religious worship, which belongs to God alone, is, in the scriptures, ascribed to the Spirit equally with the Father and the Son. Prayer, one of the most solemn parts of the worship of the militant church, is performed to the Spirit, no less than the Father and the Son. The apostolical benediction, quoted already, is most explicit and full—The grace of the Lord Jesus Christ, and the love of God, and the communion of the Holy Ghost, be with you all. 2 Cor. xiii. 14. To which I might add the Apostle John’s prayer in behalf of the Asiatic churches—Rev. i. 4, 5. Baptism, the initiatory seal of the everlasting covenant, is administered in the name of the Holy Ghost, no less than of the Father and the Son. Matth. xxviii. 19. In the

5th place, As an irrefragable proof of the divinity of the Holy Ghost, he is affirmed to be not merely equal to the Father and the Son, but one with them. So the text prefixed to this Lecture speaks—There are Three that bear record in heaven, the Father, the Word, and the Holy Ghost, and these Three are one. How manifest is the difference between the three witnesses in heaven, of whom the text speaks, and the three witnesses on earth, to which the following verse refers! As for the latter, it is said, they agree in one. They are one in design. But the three celestial witnesses are one in nature, as well as design. One individual nature is common to them all. If, therefore, any one of them be God, each of them must be God.

It is, in the answer, asserted, that the three persons in the Godhead are not only God, but one God. That God is one we saw on a former occasion. The Father is God. The Son is God. The Holy Ghost is God. And all the Three are one God. For though, as persons, they be different, one undivided Godhead belongs to them all. That God is one, reason teaches, and revelation declares. Accordingly, as a further illustration of this important point, it is

V. Affirmed, that the three persons in the Godhead are the same in substance, equal in power and glory. It is not merely affirmed that they are equal. Equal, no doubt, they are. But this is not all. Might not a mere equality comport with Tritheism itself? Three human persons may be equal. They possess three natures similar; even specifically the same. But, though they may be specifically, they cannot be numerically the same. The substance of any one of them is in reality different from that of another of them. But, as for the Three divine, they are not merely similar, but the same in substance. With great precision do the Compilers of the Catechism express themselves on this sublime subject. Against the heresies of earlier, as well as later times, do they guard us. In two instances especially has this fundamental article been attacked.

At an early period was it impugned in relation to the distinction of persons in the Godhead. The heresy of the Sabellians of the third century, so denominated from Sabellius, an Egyptian philosopher, the founder of the sect, every reader of church history knows. What they held, in general, as I hinted already, is—That in the Godhead there is only one person, who sustains and acts in three different characters. The Arians of the fourth century allowed that there are three persons, the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost. But, that these persons are one God, the same in substance, equal in power and glory, they deny.

Accordingly, the Compilers of this judicious compend of the Christian religion, having, in the preceding part of the answer, asserted, in opposition to the ancient Sabellians and their followers, that in the undivided Godhead there are three persons, the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost, they, in the latter part of it, affirm, in opposition to Arianism and all the abettors of it, that these three persons are one God, the same in substance, equal in power and glory. That the Son and the Holy Ghost, no less than the Father, are God, I have, I hope, sufficiently proved already. Now, if the second and third persons, equally with the first, be God, he and they must be one God; and the same in substance, as well as equal in power and glory. A diversity of divine essences there cannot be. Such a supposition is absurd in the extreme. Reason, no less than revelation, remonstrates against it.

These divine persons, it is added, are equal in power and glory. The preceding part of the particular relates to their oneness in essence. One essence or substance, nature or Godhead, belongs to them all. This refers to their personal equality. As persons they are not inferior, but equal one to another. Two instances are here mentioned, in which they appear to be equal—in power and glory.

  1. Power. Of power, as an essential perfection of the Godhead, I have spoken already. I called it an essential perfection. It is not peculiar to any one of the sacred Three, but common to them all. In power, according to this view of it, they may be said to be not only equal, but the same. The expression, however, is varied here. They are affirmed to be the same in substance, and equal in power. The reason, probably, is this. Power here may be intended to signify not so much the divine perfection itself, as the effects of it; the great and glorious works, which God, by his power, has produced. In relation to such glorious works, it may be proper to say that they are equal. Though such works be the effects of that power which is essential and common to them all, in the accomplishment of them they act, in a manner calculated for the manifestation of their distinct personal characters, and the mysterious order in which they subsist. The Father works by the Son, not the Son by the Father; the Father and the Son by the Spirit, not the Spirit by the Father and the Son. This is the case in the works of creation, as well as redemption. By his Son, God the Father is said to have made the worlds; not the Son by the Father, but the Father by the Son. Heb. i. 2. By his Spirit, he garnished the heavens; not the Spirit by Him, but He by the Spirit. Job xxvi. 13. Was the Father the principal agent in creation, the Son an inferior? No. In it all the persons of the Godhead were equally concerned. It was the work of the Father equally with the Son; and as really the work of the Spirit as of the Father and the Son. Accordingly, it has all along been a maxim among theological writers, that the external works of God are undivided. In what things soever God does without himself, all the persons in the Godhead are concerned. Such works are called external, to distinguish them from the internal acts by which the persons in the Godhead are known one from another. Such acts are peculiar to the persons to whom they are ascribed. The first person only begets; the second is begotten; and the third, not the first or the second, but the third person, proceeds. In all external works they concur. So they did in creation. This, as I had occasion to observe formerly, may be intimated in the plural word, by which the Creator of all worlds is expressed. Gen. i. 1. Elohim created the heavens and the earth. It was the undivided work of the co-eternal Three. Especially do they display their personal glory, and mysterious order of subsistence, in the work of our redemption. A particular part of it, indeed, is attributed to the Father, another to the Son, and another to the Holy Ghost. But in the contrivance of it, the Son and the Spirit concur with the Father. The counsel of peace was between the Father, the infinite contriver, and the Son and the Spirit, by whom especially the grand plan was to be, in time, carried into actual execution. Zech. vi. 13. The impetration of it is peculiarly ascribed to the Son. But was the Son alone in this part of the work? What saith the Son himself on this head? Behold the hour cometh, yea, is now come, that ye shall be scattered, every man to his own, and shall leave me alone; and yet I am not alone, because the Father is with me. John xvi. 32. Was the Spirit as well as the Father with the Son in this work? Yes. The Spirit was in him superabundantly. Jesus being full of the Holy Ghost, returned from Judea, and was led by the Spirit into the wilderness. Luke. iv. 1.

The effectual application of our redemption is attributed to the Holy Ghost. But is this divine person alone in the applicatory part of the work? No. The Father and the Son concur with him in it. To exemplify this in one instance—our regeneration is, on one occasion, ascribed to the Father, on another to the Son, and on a third to the Holy Ghost. To the Father, in Eph. ii. 1. You hath he, the God of our Lord Jesus Christ, the Father of glory, who raised Christ from the dead, and set him on his own right hand in the heavenly places, and gave him to be head over all things to the church—You hath He quickened who were dead in trespasses and sins. To the Son, it is likewise ascribed in John v. 21. As the Father raiseth up the dead, and quickeneth them, even so the Son quickeneth whom he will. And to the Holy Ghost, it is attributed in John iii. 5. Jesus answered, Verily, verily, I say unto thee, Except a man be born of water, and, or even, of the Spirit, he cannot enter into the kingdom of God.

The Son, the second person, having assumed the character of our Mediator or Redeemer, performs a peculiar part in the œconomy of our redemption. But the answer speaks rather of the co-eternal Three in their original characters. As such they are all equally concerned in those wonderful works, which are especially the effects of power. Wisdom and goodness, indeed, no less than power, appear in all those works. But, though goodness prompts God to work in both the world and the church, and though all his works bespeak deep design, the result of the most consummate wisdom; power, in an especial manner, is immediately exerted and displayed in the accomplishment of all the works of God. For this obvious reason may power be expressly mentioned here.

The divine Three are said to be equal in glory, as well as in power. Equal in the performance of such great works, as necessarily indicate power peculiar to God, they are, of course, equal in the glory that accrues from them. Though, according to the mysterious order in which they subsist, the Father may be said to precede the Son, and the Son the Spirit; the Son is not, either in power or in glory, inferior to the Father; nor is the Spirit, in the one respect or the other, inferior, either to the Father or the Son. Is creation the joint work of the undivided Three? The glory of it never is to be ascribed to the Father to the exclusion of the Son: or to the Father and the Son to the exclusion of the Spirit. As it is a work in which they were all equally concerned, equal glory results from it to them all. The glory of redemption, no less than of creation, is due, and ascribed in heaven and on earth, by angels and men, to the undivided Three; to the Son no less than to the Father, and to the Spirit equally with the Father and the Son. From what has been said on the sublime mystery of the Trinity, I might make several

Reflections. And, first of all, What has been said suggests to us one of the many instances, in which revealed religion is superior to natural. How deficient is the latter! What glorious discoveries does the former make! Not only does it teach that there is a God; but that in one undivided Godhead there are three distinct persons; the Father, the Son, and the Spirit, not inferior, but equal one to another. Mysteries innumerable, indeed, have we in nature. But what superior mysteries have we in religion! May not this of the Trinity be said to be the chief of them? Let us admire and adore what we never can comprehend.

2dly, Here is one of the numberless instances, in which we may see the absurdity of making our comprehension the standard of our belief; and the importance of distinguishing between what transcends reason and what is contrary to it. Infinitely, indeed, does the mystery of the sacred Trinity transcend our comprehension and reason. But contrary to sound reason it is not. Fully and clearly is it revealed in the sacred oracles. Indispensably are we bound, therefore, to believe it. That it is we certainly know; though to comprehend and explain it we never will pretend.

3dly, The sublime mystery of the sacred Trinity is such, that universal nature cannot furnish any thing similar to it; and, therefore, to pretend to represent it by any similitude is, in my apprehension, absurd and dangerous. That many excellent writers, solicitous to instruct their readers, have borrowed from creation different similitudes to assist them in forming some faint idea or conception of this sublime mystery, is well known. From the heavens above, from the earth below, and even from themselves, have they taken their similitudes. That glorious luminary which we call our sun, has been supposed to furnish us with a fit emblem of the mystery of the Trinity. The body of the sun has been understood to represent the Father, the light which proceeds from it the Son, and its heat the Holy Ghost. A fountain of water, it has been pretended, is a representation of the Trinity; the origin of the fountain in the bowels of the earth, of the Father; the springing of it, of the Son; and the rivulet which is constantly supplied by it, of the Spirit. It has been accommodated to three different kinds of life, vegetative, sensitive, and rational, in man. A variety of other similitudes have been used to enable us to form a distinct conception of the great mystery of one Godhead in three persons, and three persons in one Godhead. But how unfit and unworthy are all such representations! Such a method of explaining and accounting for the Trinity is, in my opinion, most unjustifiable. That it is well intended, I know. But it is most derogatory to the sublime subject; and calculated to produce in us conceptions most unworthy of it. Between the Trinity and every thing in creation there is an infinite disproportion. To whom will ye liken me, saith God, and make me equal, and compare me, that we may be like? Isa. xlvi. 5.

4thly, What reason have we to admire and adore the wisdom and the grace manifested in the œconomy of our redemption? Apt are we to reason thus—“Might not God have confirmed man in his original state of felicity and dignity? Why did he not prevent his fall? Could he not easily have done it? Why did he it not?” But, O man! who art thou that repliest against God? Shall the thing formed say to him that formed it, Why hast thou made me thus? Hath not the potter power over the clay? For every thing that the All-wise God does, or permits to be done, he has reasons worthy of himself. The fall of man, he, no doubt, permitted; otherwise it could not have happened. But did he not permit it for the most important reasons; and with the most merciful views? From it he has taken occasion to manifest his perfections; and, in an especial manner, the different persons in his mysterious essence, in such a conspicuous manner as he has not done in his other works. In creation, his goodness, and his wisdom, and his power, are manifested. But in redemption, the undivided Three display their personal glory, and the mysterious order in which they subsist, in a way for which there would have been no occasion, had not the fall of man been permitted.

In fine, Let us endeavour to improve the revelation of the mysterious Trinity, in a manner corresponding to the designs and views which God had in favouring us with it. With ineffable delight and unutterable wonder, let us contemplate it. Is not this employment worthy of angelic as well as human intelligences? Will not this be an essential part of the incessant and unwearied employment of the blissful inhabitants of the higher world for ever and ever? Let us especially contemplate and adore the undivided Three, concurring and performing their respective parts in redemption. What security have we here for the completion of the arduous work! Is it possible for a work to miscarry in which the co-eternal Three are engaged? Was the eternal Son all-sufficient to purchase our redemption? No less sufficient is the eternal Spirit to apply it. What strong consolation then may they have, who by faith have fled for refuge to lay hold on Christ offered to them in the gospel! Let us claim the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, for our God and our Father. Let us claim his Son as our Saviour, as our kinsman-Redeemer, as our elder brother. Not only as the second person, but as our Redeemer, is he the Son of God, and heir of all things. That, in the latter view, as well as the former, the filial character is applied to him in the scriptures, and that it is in his right, as the first-born of the family of God, and the primary heir of the heavenly inheritance, we become children and heirs of God, I will have occasion to show when I explain the account of our adoption in the sequel of the Catechism. Let us employ the Spirit in that important and salutary work; for the accomplishment of which he has been sent into the church, and is to continue in it till the end of the world. Let us daily apply to him, for instruction, for sanctifying influence, and for spiritual consolation. For, if we have not the Spirit of Christ, notwithstanding the profession we have made, and all the external privileges of which we are partakers, we are none of his.

Unto the eternal Father, unto his eternal Son, and unto the co-eternal Spirit, one God, be ascribed equal and undivided honours, in heaven and on earth, for ever and ever! Amen.