An Exposition, Critical, Doctrinal, and Practical, of the Assembly’s Shorter Catechism (1788), Michael Arthur · PDF

Sin

1 John iii. 4.

Whosoever committeth sin transgresseth also the law: for sin is the transgression of the law.

The high privileges, of which all true believers are partakers, this inspired Apostle traces to their origin and spring. He furnishes us with a certain criterion, by which we may discern whether we be partakers of them or not. That discriminating and efficacious grace, from which they originally flow, incites every person that obtains it to study universal purity both internal and external. In order to excite us all to this useful study, the Apostle reminds us of sin, both as a hateful and a hurtful thing. Of sin he gives us a concise and a comprehensive definition in the words which I have chosen to introduce this Lecture. Whosoever committeth sin, says he, transgresseth also the law; for sin is the transgression of the law.

To the Apostle’s account of sin the description, which the Compilers of the Shorter Catechism have given us of it, agrees. Sin is any want of conformity unto, or transgression of, the law of God.

Formerly we saw man exalted almost to heaven. Last occasion we beheld him falling as a star from heaven; and we found that his unhappy fall was occasioned by sin. Is it not, therefore, most natural to ask now, What is sin? If its fatal effects be such, what must itself be? The answer, which I have now repeated, informs us. This answer naturally resolves itself into two parts; the subject spoken of, sin; and what is affirmed of it, it is any want of conformity unto, or transgression of the law of God. These two parts of the subject, however, I shall consider, not separately, but together.

To intimate the vast number of sins in the world, the great complication of evils which sin has in it, and its manifold direful effects, the scripture uses a multiplicity of synonimous expressions, which I am not now to enumerate, far less canvass. As for the word translated sin, if we attend to the etymology and proper signification of it, it will, perhaps, be found to be borrowed from Archers, who, in hunting or fighting, shoot with bows and arrows, but miss their mark. This method of shooting in ancient times, while fire-arms were not invented, was almost universal; and to it the scripture appears often to allude. Is there not here a plain intimation, that there is a certain mark, to which all our aims and actions ought to be ultimately directed? Whether we eat or drink, or whatsoever we do, we should do all to the glory of God.

Accordingly, in the answer, there is mention of a law, in the want of conformity to which, or a transgression of it, sin ever consists. Under this law man ever has been. The design of it is to regulate every part of his conduct outward and inward. Conformity to it ever is his duty; and disconformity to it ever is his sin. This is the test by which sin and duty are known and distinguished the one from the other. I am not now to give you an account of the various acceptations of the word law in the scriptures, or of the several laws which God has imposed upon man.—A summary view of the law, however, I am obliged to introduce here, in order to pave the way for what I am to say in relation to sin. Sin ever supposes a law; for, as the Apostle speaks, where no law is, there is no transgression. Rom. iv. 15.

Now the law, in a want of conformity to which, or a transgression of it, sin consists, comes under a twofold consideration, as natural and as revealed. The natural law consists in certain inbred notions of right and wrong, good and evil, which belong to us as rational beings; which, therefore, we bring into the world with us, and which accordingly obtain among mankind in all parts of our world. This is the law, for disconformity to which the nations of the world, without the boundaries of the visible church, are to be punished. For, as the Apostle speaks, there is no respect of persons with God. For as many as have sinned without law shall also perish without law; and as many as have sinned in the law shall be judged by the law. For not the hearers of the law are just before God, but the doers of the law shall be justified. For when the Gentiles which have not the law do by nature the things contained in the law, these, having not the law, are a law unto themselves. Which shew the work of the law written on their hearts, their conscience also bearing witness, and their thoughts the mean while accusing or else excusing one another, in the day when God shall judge the secrets of men by Jesus Christ, according to my gospel. Rom. ii. 11,—16.

There is the revealed law. This is contained in the scriptures of the Old and New Testament. For, as I said in a former Lecture, the scriptures contain especially two things; the law, which discovers sin, and the woful effects of it; and the gospel, which reveals the Saviour and his salvation. The revealed law admits of a twofold consideration. It may be understood in a larger, or in a more limited sense. By the former I understand what is commonly called the Mosaic law. This includes not only the moral law, which is of universal and endless obligation; but the ceremonial and judicial laws, which were of only limited and temporary use. The ceremonial law respected the Jews in their ecclesiastical capacity, or as a church; and regulated the numerous rites and ceremonies of their peculiar worship. The judicial law considered them in their political capacity, or as a nation. The former is now totally abrogated. Christ is the end of the law; not only of the moral law in point of perfection, but of the ceremonial in point of abolition. The latter, so far as the Jewish polity was peculiar and different from every other model of civil government, has also ceased.

The Mosaic law included also the moral, as contradistinguished from the ceremonial and judicial laws. This is what I understand by the revealed law in the limited acceptation of it. It is, I said, of endless as well as universal obligation. It binds Christians now no less than it did the Jews of old. This is the law, by a want of conformity to which, or a transgression of it, we sin. It shows what is conform, and what is contrary, to the will of God. The former it enjoins. The latter it prohibits. Various duties does it require; and various sins does it forbid. It extends to the springs and motives of our actions, as well as our external actions themselves. In the former as well as the latter, may there be a want of conformity to it.

This universal law admits of different forms. Accordingly it has different epithets given to it. It is on one occasion denominated the law of works; and on another the law of Christ. Rom. iii. 27. Gal. vi. 2. The law of works is the scriptural name of the covenant of works. All unbelievers are under it in this form. They are under it both in its precept and in its penalty; or, in other words, in both its commanding and condemning power. From it, as a covenant of works, or, in the language of the New Testament, as the law of works, all true believers are totally and for ever delivered. In its federal form it was, both in its precept and its penalty, fulfilled and satisfied by their great Surety in their stead, for this very end that they might be delivered from it. Has the moral law, therefore, no power over them? Is its obligation as to them totally relaxed? Far from it. They are under it in all its precepts and parts. They are under special obligations to study universal conformity in nature and practice to it. But they are under it in a new form; not as a proper covenant, only as a law, and under the endearing consideration of the law of Christ.

It is natural to ask here, what does the Apostle intend by the law of Christ? or, in other words, what is the difference between the moral law as the law of works, under which the unbeliever is; and as the law of Christ, under which the believer is? All that I shall say in answer to this question is, that, as the law of works, it promises life as the reward of obedience, and threatens death as the punishment of disobedience; but, as the law of Christ, it neither confers life upon believers for their obedience, nor punishes their disobedience with death. Those who are under it in the latter sense are exempted from death and entitled to life, in virtue of the vicarious obedience and satisfaction of their Surety, who fulfilled the precept and endured the penalty of the law of works, in their room and stead. Christ, says the Apostle for other believers as well as himself, hath redeemed us from the curse of the law, being made a curse for us. For when the fulness of the time was come, God sent forth his Son, made of a woman, made under the law, to redeem them that were under the law, that we might receive the adoption of sons. Gal. iii. 13. and iv. 4, 5.

Thus are all true believers, Gentile as well as Jewish, the weak as well as the strong, delivered as fully and effectually from the precept, as well as from the penalty, of the law of works, as if they had never been under it. To be under it, as the law of Christ, they account no slavery, but the most excellent liberty. Universal conformity in heart and life to it under this endearing consideration is their unfeigned wish and aim. All the duties which it requires are they solicitous to perform; and from all the sins which it forbids are they careful to abstain. From evangelical principles and motives, with the most generous aims and views, do they wish to perform every known duty, and to avoid every known sin. From faith in Christ, for both assistance and acceptance, and from love to him as their Sovereign, as well as their Saviour, do they act. How different is the evangelical obedience of believers under the law of Christ, from the legal, mercenary performances of self-righteous professors who are still attached to the law of works! The religious services of believers are a work of faith and a labour of love. 1 Thess. i. 3. The love of Christ, no less than his authority, powerfully and sweetly constrains them.—But on these things, how important and interesting soever, I must not now enlarge. They will come under review in the sequel.

The definition of sin in the answer consists of two branches, and includes in it two things; a want of conformity to the law, and a transgression of it. The word transgression, indeed, sometimes denotes all sin. The Compilers of the Catechism, however, seem to distinguish between a want of conformity to the law and a transgression of it. Natural, therefore, is it to ask, Do these two expressions signify two different things? And, if they do, what is intended by the one and what by the other? I answer in two particulars.

First, By a want of conformity to the law, as distinguished from a transgression of it, has been understood original sin in opposition to actual. But to the accuracy of this distinction it has been objected, that original sin has in it a transgression of the law, as well as non-conformity to it. Original sin, as we will see in the sequel, has a positive as well as a negative part. It comprehends in it not only the want of original righteousness, but the guilt of Adam’s first sin imputed to us, and the universal corruption of nature which is inherent in us. Is Adam’s first sin placed to our account? Is this an ingredient in that original sin which we bring into the world with us? Then original sin includes not only a want of conformity to the law, but a transgression of it.

That Adam’s first sin, which, though not committed by us, is imputed to us, includes a transgression of the law, as well as a want of conformity to it, cannot be doubted.—Hence

Secondly, By a want of conformity to the law, as distinguished from a transgression of it, may be intended any sin of omission, in contradistinction to sins of commission. Though we refrain from all the sins the law forbids, if we omit any one of the duties it requires, we sin. This the answer evidently intimates—Sin is any want, &c. Manifold are the respects in which there may be a want of conformity to it. It may suffice to mention two particulars here.

(1.) It may be in the person himself by whom the obedience is performed. The law demands conformity in the man, as well as in his actions. He must be what it requires him to be, as well as do what it requires him to do. All the powers of his soul must be disposed, and all the members of his body employed, in the manner which it prescribes. Knowledge in his understanding, rectitude in his will, regularity and purity in his affections, does the law indispensably require. With his bodily organs, as well as his intellectual powers, does it require him to glorify God. Now, if in any of all these instances there be a want of conformity to the law, or if any of all these things be lacking, the person is not what the law requires him to be; and, therefore, is a sinner. Thus the unregenerated and unsanctified sinner, in whom the good work has not yet been begun, is in all these respects deficient; and, therefore, universally sinful.

(2.) I might consider this want of conformity in relation to the two tables of the holy law; the different precepts which belong to them severally; and the numerous duties which each of its commandments requires. Were we conformed to the first table, but not the second; in other words, were we disposed, as we should be, toward God, but not toward our neighbour, we would be found deficient and wanting. Were we to obey all its precepts and perform all the duties which they enjoin, one precept or one duty only excepted, we would still be deficient and lacking. Numerous are its precepts, and numerous are the duties, which each of them inculcates. It only is summarily comprehended in the ten commandments. Each of the ten comprehends a great number of particular precepts. Were we to review the whole sacred writings, and to select from them the numerous commandments which they contain, to what a great number would they amount! Under one or another of the ten precepts of the decalogue is each of them, however, comprehended. To one or another of the precepts of that comprehensive summary may they be reduced. Now, if any one of these many commandments be neglected, or any one of the many duties, which they enjoin, be omitted, there is a want of conformity to the holy law. What reason then have we to say, Who among us can comprehend the nature or the number of his errors and offences? What occasion has each of us to adopt the Psalmist’s humble acknowledgment—Innumerable evils have compassed me about: mine iniquities have taken hold upon me; so that I am not able to look up. They are more than the hairs of mine head; therefore my heart faileth me. Psal. xl. 12. Well may each of us exclaim with holy Job, Behold I am vile; what shall I answer thee? I will lay mine hand upon my mouth. Job xl. 4.

What I have already advanced might suffice for a brief explanation of the answer. But, that I may impress upon your minds the intrinsic evil, and the fatal effects, of sin; that I may excite every careless person among you to consider his sin and his danger; that I may show you your need of the Saviour and his salvation, I will subjoin two additional observations, tending to the farther elucidation of this grave subject.

First, Sin admits of various divisions. It is usually divided into

(1.) Original and actual. Of original sin, and its several ingredients, a subsequent answer gives us a particular account. This is the sin which we, as the descendents of fallen Adam, bring into the world with us. In it each of us was conceived. This is the sin which especially the Psalmist confesses in the fifty-first Psalm. This may be called original sin, especially for two reasons. It is communicated to us from Adam, the origin and the common parent of the numerous individuals of the human species. And it is the spring of all actual transgressions. It is the foul fountain; they the streams which flow from it. It is the corrupt root; they the branches which spring from it. Actual sin, in contradistinction to original, is that which we commit in our own persons. Original sin is as real as actual. But that sin, the guilt of which is imputed to us, and in which all our other sins originate, was not our personal act. It was committed long before we existed. But so soon as we come into the world, and are capable of doing evil in our own persons, we begin to commit sin. So the scripture teaches; and the universal experience of mankind evinces it—The wicked are estranged from the womb; they go astray as soon as they be born, speaking lies. Psal. lviii. 3. There are sins of

(2.) Omission and of commission. The law to which sin ever has a relation, and without which there can be no sin, requires one thing and forbids another. The former, for this very reason, is a duty to be performed by us; the latter, for the same reason, a sin from which we are to abstain. Each of the precepts of the divine law has both a positive and a negative part; the one expressed, and the other implied. The precept which explicitly requires a particular duty, implicitly, and by necessary consequence, forbids the contrary sin. The precept, on the other hand, which expressly inhibits a particular sin, implicitly, and by necessary consequence, requires the duty to which that sin is immediately opposed.—There are,

(3.) Transgressions, of the first and of the second table of the divine law. The distribution of the ten commandments into two classes or tables, the first containing four, and the second six precepts, is here presupposed. The former relates to the duty which we owe immediately to God; the latter to the duty which we owe immediately to our neighbour. Now, as God is the Author of the whole law, a violation of the one table, no less than of the other, is sin. In what relates to the worship of God, as well as in what relates to equity between man and man, may we sin. Error, no less than immorality, is sin. The former is contrary to the first table, or what our Lord calls the first great commandment, no less than the latter is contrary to the second. Does not the first great commandment enjoin an explicit profession of all the sacred truths, and a conscientious observation of all the holy institutions which the Head of the church has delivered to her in the scriptures, to be preserved, in her, unadulterated and uncorrupted to the end of the world? Must not the denial of any of those sacred truths, or the non-observation of any of these holy ordinances, therefore, be a transgression of the first great commandment, no less than injustice, or oppression, or any other immorality, is a violation of the second? There are

(4.) Secret and public, known and unknown, sins; sins of heart and of life. Daily do we break the commandments in thought, as well as in word and deed. The heart, as the principal part of the man, is the chief seat of both good and evil. The heart is deceitful above all things, and desperately wicked; who can know it? Jer. xvii. 9. O Jerusalem! wash thine heart from wickedness, that thou mayest be saved. How long shall vain thoughts lodge within you? Chap. iv. 14. Out of the heart proceed evil thoughts, murders, adulteries, fornications, thefts, false witness, blasphemies. These are the things which defile a man. Matth. xv. 19, 20. Cleanse your hands, ye sinners, and purify your hearts, ye double-minded. Jam. iv. 8.—The impurity which has its chief seat in the heart, diffuses itself, as a noxious leaven, through the whole man, all the members of his body, as well as all the powers of his soul; and all his actions, natural, civil, and religious. Accordingly, the Apostle speaks of a twofold filthiness; the filthiness of the flesh, and the filthiness of the spirit. For thus he bespeaks the Corinthian converts, Having therefore these promises, dearly beloved, let us cleanse ourselves from all filthiness of the flesh and spirit, perfecting holiness in the fear of God. 2 Cor. vii. 1. And, writing to the Hebrew Christians, he speaks of having our hearts sprinkled from an evil conscience, and our bodies washed with pure water. Heb. x. 22. The different expressions here may refer both to the constituent parts of our nature infected with sin, and the two ingredients of sin, guilt and defilement; as also the two capital blessings of justification and sanctification. During the typical dispensation, various sprinklings and washings obtained; both blood and water were used; both the priests and the people were washed. When the great High Priest of our profession was offered, and his sacred side was pierced, both blood and water proceeded from it. Guilty sinners he justifies; and the unholy he sanctifies. Thus sin is, at once, a dangerous and a defiling, a hateful and a hurtful, thing.—To all which I shall only add, in a word, that sins are distinguished by

(5.) The aggravations which attend them. One is attended with lesser, another with greater aggravations. Of the various ways in which sin may be aggravated and rendered heinous, the after part of the Catechism speaks. That sin ever is a great evil, the scripture every where teaches. What Joseph said with regard to the sin which he was solicited to commit, applies to every other sin. Shall I do this great wickedness, says he, and sin against God? Gen. xxxix. 9. Was it a great wickedness because it was against God? Then every sin must be great wickedness; for every sin is against God. Such was the view David had of his sin. Against thee, says he, thee only have I sinned, and done this evil in thy sight. Psal. li. 4. Often are sins committed with a high hand. Often does the presumptuous offender seem to defy Omnipotence itself. Evil is sin in itself. Bitter are the fruits which it produces.

Secondly, Sin is attended with guilt, and with filth. Often do you read and hear of the guilt and of the filth of sin. The question is, whether you understand what is intended by these expressions. In order that I may give you some idea of the guilt and of the filth of sin, you must recollect that sin ever has a relation to a law, in the want of conformity to which, or a transgression of it, it ever consists; and in these two ingredients, or adjuncts of it, it relates to the law in different views. The supreme Legislator is the infinite God. Upon the law his authority is instamped. A violation of it, therefore, includes a contempt of the highest authority. Thus is guilt contracted, and the sinner incurs condign punishment. Guilt, therefore, is that which renders persons obnoxious to punishment. Accordingly, when a culprit is tried in a human judicature, whether it be for an arbitrary or a capital punishment, the question is, Guilty, or not guilty? And according as there is evidence or not evidence of his guilt, or, in other words, as he is found guilty, or not guilty, he is punished or not punished.—Thus a guilty person only can be justly punishable. Vain is it to object here, that the Son of God, though most innocent and holy, was subjected to punishment. For, though he never contracted guilt in his own person, there was a real translation of guilt and punishment from sinners to him, as their engaged and fulfilling Surety. Jehovah laid on him the iniquity of us all. Insupportable load!

Again the law may be viewed as a transcript of the moral perfections of the Deity. Accordingly sin, which implies disconformity to that law, or a transgression of it, bespeaks contrariety to the divine purity. Thus it has in it filth and impurity. The stain of it is indelible for any thing which creatures can do in order to wash it out. In vain do sinners apply nitre and much soap that they may remove it. For though thou shouldest wash thee with nitre, and take thee much soap, yet thine iniquity is marked before me, saith the Lord God. Jer. ii. 22. If I wash myself with snow-water, saith Job, and make my hands ever so clean; yet shalt thou plunge me in the ditch, and mine own works shall abhor me. Job ix. 30, 31. Is it any wonder then that this holy man adds, I abhor myself, and repent in dust and ashes. Nay, such is the stain of sin, that one thing only can wash it out, the blood of Jesus Christ, the Son of God; and his blood only cleanseth from sin, and all sin. 1 John i. 7. This is the full and the free fountain which, according to Old Testament prophecy, is now by the gospel opened to the household of our antitypical David, and to the numerous inhabitants of our spiritual Jerusalem, for sin, even for uncleanness. Zech. xiii. 1. Each of us our condescending Redeemer may be understood to bespeak now, as he once did an eminent Apostle, If I wash thee not, thou hast no part with me. John xiii. 8.

From these few hints you may form some idea of sin in both its guilt and filth; of the tendency it has both to the dishonour of God and the destruction of sinners.—To this short account of sin I shall subjoin a few reflections for improvement. And,

I may, in the 1st place, Take notice of the vast extent of that law, in a disconformity to which, or a transgression of it, sin consists. It extends to men in all ages of the world, earlier and later; to Adam himself, and to the last of his numerous posterity; to men in all quarters and corners of the earth, the east and the west, the south and the north; to men of all descriptions, high and low, rich and poor, superiors, inferiors, and equals. It extends to the whole of the man; his person and his actions. What an unknown variety of duties does it enjoin! What an unknown variety of sins does it inhibit! Is the law of such extent? How foolish, not to say vain, must it be for any of mankind fallen to expect eternal felicity according to the tenor and terms of it!

In the 2d place, Most essential is the difference between the law and the gospel; and most necessary is it for both preachers and hearers to attend to it. The law discovers sin and misery. But of a Saviour, or of salvation, it says nothing. But what the law cannot do the gospel does. It reveals an all-sufficient, and ever-ready Saviour; and a salvation, in all respects, such as our necessitous case requires. The law, in short, is a collection of divine precepts. The gospel, properly so called, has no precepts belonging to it. It is an assemblage of promises, to us, most gratuitous and unconditional; for they belong to that superior covenant, which, though to the great Surety, strictly conditional, and, in the highest sense of the words, a covenant of works, is to us altogether unconditional; and, in the fullest sense of the word, a covenant of grace.

In the 3d place, The necessity of the knowledge of the law, in order to the knowledge of sin. Are we, in particular circumstances, at a loss to know what is sin? Let us attend to the law, to what it enjoins and to what it inhibits. Duty it ever requires. Sin it ever forbids. If the thing in question, therefore, be required, it must be a duty; if forbidden, it must be a sin. Are we solicitous to know what the law enjoins, and what it inhibits? Let us conscientiously, and with assiduity, search the scriptures. They contain a revelation of the law, as well as of the gospel. Do they contain such a full and clear revelation of our duty? Are we, after all, ignorant of it, or of any part of it? How inexcusable is our ignorance? What excuse can we plead? Let us remember the words of our Lord—If I had not come, and spoken unto them, they had not had sin; but now they have no cloak for their sin.

In the 4th place, Numerous, as well as heinous, must our sins be. What a variety of commandments belong to the law! What a multiplicity of duties do they enjoin! What numberless sins do they forbid! Now, which of all the duties required have we not neglected? Of which of all the sins forbidden are we totally innocent? Innumerable, therefore, as well as aggravated, must our sins be. Were we offered a full and final pardon of them all, on condition of our giving a full enumeration and detail of them, on this condition, easy as it may seem, we never could obtain it.

In the 5th place, We see the necessity of that convincing work which the Redeemer has promised to send his Spirit to perform in the church on earth. Solicitous to satisfy his disconsolate followers, concerning the propriety and happy consequences of his departure from them, the Redeemer bespeaks them in this endearing manner—It is expedient for you that I go away; for if I go not away, the Comforter will not come unto you; but if I depart, I will send him unto you; and when he is come, he will reprove the world of sin, of righteousness, and of judgment; of sin, because they believe not in me. John xvi. 7, 8, 9. How ignorant of sin are multitudes! How small account do they make of it! To them, indeed, it is a light thing. But to the convinced and awakened sinner it is no such light thing. His guilt stares him in the face. Hell is uncovered and naked before him. His heart smites him. He is his own accuser and his own judge. He has the most fearful apprehensions. His heart fails. A wounded spirit who can bear? The effects of his inward anxiety and distress are, perhaps, visible on his outward man. His life abhorreth bread, and his soul dainty meat. His flesh is consumed away that it cannot be seen; and his bones that were not seen, stick out. Yea, his soul draweth near unto the grave, and his life unto the destroyers. Doleful case! What an accursed thing is sin? To what misery, temporal and eternal, does it expose sinners? What alarming words from a sin-punishing God are these—If ye will not be reformed by me by these things, but will walk contrary unto me; then will I also walk contrary unto you, and will punish you yet seven times more for your sins. Lev. xxvi. 23, 24. The thing is certain, and therefore, the vision is doubled; the threatening is repeated. If ye will not, for all this, hearken unto me, but walk contrary unto me; then I will walk contrary unto you in fury; and I, even I, will chastise you seven times for your sins. Verses 27, 28.

In the 6th place, We see the indispensable necessity, and the admirable fitness of the remedy which God, in rich grace, has provided for our lost world. Sinners are we all by nature. Sinners are we by practice. Great is the guilt, and great is the danger, which we all have incurred. We have defiled, as well as destroyed, ourselves. But Jesus saves from sin, and he delivers from wrath. From the power and the practice of sin, as well as its punishment, does he free. He who is made of God to us righteousness, is also made of God to us sanctification.

In fine, How blissful and happy are the inhabitants of the heavenly world! From sin, as well as from misery, are they completely and for ever delivered. The inhabitant of that land shall not say I am sick. The reason is, The people that dwell therein are forgiven their iniquity.