An Exposition, Critical, Doctrinal, and Practical, of the Assembly’s Shorter Catechism (1788), Michael Arthur · PDF

The Fall of Man

Eccl. vii. 29.

Lo, this only have I found, that God hath made man upright; but they have sought out many inventions.

Immutability is one of the incommunicable perfections by which the divine Being is distinguished from every being of the created kind. Holy and happy was man in his original state. But mutability belongs to all the creatures. God made man upright; but he soon unmade himself. So speaks the text. God made man upright; but he found out many inventions, by which he dishonoured God, and destroyed himself. Sudden is the transition in the text from man’s first to his fallen state. Sudden was man’s fall from a state of holiness and happiness into a state of sin and misery. This is that unhappy change of state that man at an early period underwent; of which we have a description in the following answer of the Catechism, which I am now to introduce and explain—Our first parents being left to the freedom of their own will, fell from the estate wherein they were created, by sinning against God.

Of the creation of our first parents, and of the holy and happy state in which they were at first placed, we have heard already. Of the unhappy change of state which they suddenly underwent, commonly known by the name of the fall, I am now to speak.

In the answer which I have repeated, and am now to explain, we find the following particulars.

I. The persons immediately concerned in this dreadful catastrophe, our first parents. They were the first human pair, and the common parents of the numerous individuals of mankind who have been born in the ages which are past, and are to be born in the ages which are to come. They were our parents. We are their children. The genealogy of mankind, in all parts of our world, may be traced back from son to father, through all the past ages of the world, till we reach that early period at which only two human beings actually existed, and we all lay in their loins. Why then should one of mankind hate or despise another? We are all brethren. The high and the rich need not look down with contempt on the mean and the low. One specific nature is common to them all. They all have one common father. Of one blood God hath made all nations of men that dwell on all the face of the earth. A federal, as well as a natural, relation subsists between Adam and us. He represented us in that covenant of which I gave you an account in the preceding Lecture. Therefore, when he sinned and fell, we sinned in him and fell with him.

II. How our first parents fell from their original state of dignity, as well as purity and felicity—Being left to the freedom of their own will they fell. This truly is a mysterious subject. That our first parents fell, and that we fell in and with them, experience, as well as scripture, tells us. But how they fell, it is far from being easy to explain. This is, indeed, one of the most abstruse points in revealed religion. It is attended with difficulties, the solution of which is truly hard. Vain and unnecessary is it to ask whether man has actually fallen or not. That he now is a fallen creature is a truth no less mournful than certain. He once was a holy and a happy man. How could a holy and a happy man become unholy and unhappy? In him, at his creation, there was a universal inclination to good. Whence then had he a propensity to evil? Whence did it originate?

This mystery has been explained and accounted for in a manner most derogatory to God, and subversive of the most capital doctrines of revelation. It has been pretended, that this propensity or inclination to evil was concreated with man. But could it possibly be concreated with him? Could it be of God? No. He is not, he cannot be, the author of sin, or of any sinful inclination. Had it been concreated with Adam, he must have had it even prior to his fall; nay, from the very earliest moments of his existence. But the supposition of a propensity to evil, or inclination leading to the actual commission of sin, is utterly incompatible with a state of perfect purity and felicity, and repugnant to the views the scripture gives us, and all the ideas we entertain of man’s primeval state. The supposition that there was in man from his creation such an inbred inclination to evil, that man was a sinner from his creation, or rather that sin was concreated with him, is a monstrous absurdity. An inclination to evil is evil. A sinful habit, no less than a sinful act, is sin. The holy law requires conformity to it in the heart as well as in the practice, in the inward dispositions as well as in the external actions. A want of conformity to it, as really as a transgression of it, is sin.

The supposition, I say, that an inclination to evil was concreated with man is most antiscriptural and big with absurdity. Accordingly, the answer accounts for his sin and fall in quite a different manner. He was, indeed, a holy and a happy man. But he was only a man; and, therefore, capable of change. Many creatures, indeed, both angelic and human, are unalterably confirmed in a state of holiness and happiness. But the permanency of their state does not arise from the immutability of their natures. It arises from the stability of the divine purposes. God, no doubt, could immediately have confirmed our first parents in a state of purity and felicity. But it pleased him to place them, for a season, in a state of probation and trial. As he ever is sovereign in the distribution of all his favours to the creatures, he could either give to our original progenitors, or withhold from them, that superadded grace and strength by which they might have been for ever confirmed in their original state, and not so much as a possibility left of their falling from it. It does not appear that he withdrew from Adam the grace which he had formerly given him. Easily, no doubt, could he have bestowed upon him confirming grace, by which his fall might have been absolutely prevented. But this, as I said, he might either give or withhold. And he, in sovereignty, withheld it accordingly; leaving man to his own freedom in the improvement of what he had already received. He did not in the least prompt, but only permitted, man to sin. He had given him a stock of strength sufficient for doing his duty; and left him to the freedom of his own will in the use of it.

Thus was he to stand or to fall, as he used or abused that freedom of will and choice to which he was now left; or as he made a good or bad use of that stock he had now in his hand, the improvement of which God had left to himself. He was under the most inviolable obligations to obey. He was allured to obedience from the encouraging prospect of the endless felicity which he was to obtain for himself and his posterity. He was deterred from disobedience by the most express and faithful warning of the fatal consequences of it to himself and his offspring. Far was it from being equal to him, in point of duty and of interest, whether he obeyed or disobeyed. Thus encouraged to obedience and deterred from disobedience, however, he was left to his own free choice. Inclined and encouraged as he was to good, it might have been expected that no allurement or temptation could have caused him to deviate from his duty. But, alas! mutable and uncertain are all the creatures when left to themselves.

In a mind directed and bent toward good, all good, and good only, who could have expected any evil inclination or motion ever to arise? When the choice, the competition was between God and the Devil, sin and duty, felicity and misery, who could have thought the preference ever would have been given to the latter? Mysterious and unaccountable as the origin of moral evil in the world, or the entrance of sin into it, must certainly be, from the nature of God, and from what he has discovered to us, we know that neither can man, on the one hand, be excused, nor can God, on the other, be accused. Sin, as we have repeatedly observed, he may permit. But he cannot prompt to the commission of it. God tempteth no man; neither can he be tempted of evil. Jam. i. 13.

But of the manner in which our first parents were seduced and fell, the answer to a following question gives us a more particular account. Accordingly

III. We may take notice of the unhappy change of state which our first parents experienced—They fell from the estate wherein they were created. With the most obvious propriety is it called the fall. It supposes a former state of dignity, as well as of felicity. It bespeaks a present state of infelicity and misery. High was man previous to this direful event. High was he in point of relation. He was the son of God. Luke iii. 38. High character! High was he in point of state. He was in covenant with his Maker; and his vicegerent on earth. All the other creatures in our world were subject to him. High did he stand in his Maker’s estimation and favour. High was he in point of employment. He glorified God in a manner of which all the other creatures in our lower world are incapable. He had high attainments and enjoyments. He enjoyed, as well as glorified, his Maker in a peculiar manner. Honourable, happy man!

But, alas! man, being in honour, abode not. Low is man posterior to the fall. An alien and outcast is fallen man; quite disabled for glorifying God, and disqualified for enjoying him, as well as without a title to it. Let us review him in his first state, and in his now fallen state. Let us compare, rather contrast, the one with the other. What a striking proof and humbling monument of human mutability do we behold! To what was this dismal change owing? What cause could produce such a woful effect? This question reminds me of

IV. And last particular in the answer. Our first parents fell from the estate wherein they were created by sinning against God. Sin, we see, was the cause. Our first parents fell from the holy and happy estate in which they were created, of which we have a fuller account in the preceding part of the Catechism, into that state of sin and misery, of which we have a particular account in the sequel, by sinning. Sin! evil and accursed thing! Nay, sin is the only evil thing in the universe. We speak of moral and penal evil; but strictly speaking, there is only one evil thing, sin. It only is in a qualified sense that we can call punishment evil. Accordingly, it is said to be of God. Thus he speaks—I form the light, and create darkness. I make peace and create evil, penal evil, I the Lord do all these things. Isa. xlv. 7. Vengeance is mine, I will repay it saith the Lord. Rom. xii. 19.

What an evil thing in itself is sin! and what bitter fruits does it produce! This truly is the vine of Sodom, and of the fields of Gomorrah; its grapes are grapes of gall, its clusters are bitter. Deut. xxxii. 32. What brought angels down from the celestial mansions which they originally inhabited, and consigned them over to the infernal regions? What brought our first parents out of the terrestrial paradise, and exposed them to woe and wretchedness in time and through eternity? Were I to put ten thousand such questions, one answer would suffice for them all. Sin, that evil thing, sin, is the cause of all the woes of the wretched creatures.

But to speak of either the intrinsic evil, or the awful demerit, the odious nature, or the direful effects, of sin, is only to anticipate what will come under consideration in the answers to some subsequent questions. What I have farther to say upon this subject I shall, therefore, postpone at present. To conclude—

(1.) What has been said accounts for that similarity and semblance which we all bear to the first Adam. Children are supposed to resemble their father. Adam was the common parent of all mankind. They all, as his children, resemble and imitate him. Variously, indeed, are the nations and individuals of the human race distinguished from one another. But they all bear a semblance to their original progenitor. What is affirmed of one of his immediate sons may be said of each of his remotest posterity—He is begotten in his own likeness, and after his image; his image and likeness as fallen man, in opposition to that image and likeness of God after which he was at first created. Gen. v. 3. compared with chapter i. 26, 27.

(2.) Most dangerous must it be for any of us to be left to ourselves. Whence was it that part of the angels fell while others stood? Were not the standing and the fallen angels originally in the same situation? They, no doubt, were. How then can we account for the fall of some of them, and the continuation of others in their primeval state of holiness and happiness? The account I have given of the fall of man answers the question. God confirmed part of the angels in their original state, and left others, as he also did man, to the freedom of their own will; withholding confirming grace from them, which he was not bound to give to any; and, therefore, might grant or withhold it as he pleased. Now, if it was so dangerous for holy and happy angels, for our first parents in paradise, to be left to themselves, how very dangerous must it be for us to be left to ourselves? Let him that thinketh he standeth then take heed lest he fall. 1 Cor. x. 12. O how encouraging is it to think that no believer, however weak, can fall totally or finally away! That believers may be left for their correction and their trial; and that they may fall often and grievously we know from both scripture and experience. 2 Chron. xxxii. 31. But they cannot fall totally or finally. Their final perseverance in a gracious state is infallibly insured. I will make an everlasting covenant with them, saith God, that I will not turn away from them to do them good; but I will put my fear in their hearts, that they shall not depart from me. Jer. xxxii. 40.

(3.) How very different is man’s fallen state from his original state! Often review the scripture-account of both. Compare the one with the other. The crown is fallen from our head. Wo unto us that we have sinned.

(4.) How suitable to our malady is the remedy which God in rich sovereignty has provided for us! Are we fallen creatures? Here is a wonderful expedient by which fallen man is exalted to dignity as well as felicity, superior to what he ever would have obtained had he never fallen. For when men are cast down, then thou shalt say, there is lifting up; and he shall save the humble person. Job xxii. 29. Unknown is the depth, and unknown is the heighth, of redeeming love.