Man’s First Sin
Gen. iii. 1,—7.
Now the serpent was more subtile than any beast of the field which the Lord God had made. And he said unto the woman, Yea, hath God said, Ye shall not eat of every tree of the garden? And the woman said unto the serpent, We may eat of the fruit of the trees of the garden: But of the fruit of the tree which is in the midst of the garden, God hath said, Ye shall not eat of it, neither shall ye touch it, lest ye die. And the serpent said unto the woman, Ye shall not surely die. For God doth know, that in the day ye eat thereof, then your eyes shall be opened; and ye shall be as gods, knowing good and evil. And when the woman saw that the tree was good for food, and that it was pleasant to the eyes, and a tree to be desired to make one wise; she took of the fruit thereof, and did eat; and gave also unto her husband with her, and he did eat. And the eyes of them both were opened; and they knew that they were naked: and they sewed fig-leaves together, and made themselves aprons.
This part of ancient history informs us of an event, not only most important in itself, but attended with consequences most interesting to us all. It gives us an authentic, as well as a circumstantial, account of the seduction and ruin of the original parents of mankind. Accordingly, I shall take occasion from the words read, to introduce the account which our Shorter Catechism gives us of the unhappy action by which our original ancestors fell. In this event we all were concerned; and the consequences of it we all feel. Had our first parents stood, we all would have stood. But they fell, and we all fell with them. Let us, therefore, attend to the inspired Writer’s account of the manner in which they fell. To it agrees the description which the following Answer in the Catechism gives us of that particular sin by which their fall was originally occasioned. The sin whereby our first parents fell from the estate wherein they were created was their eating the forbidden fruit.
Of the fall of man we have already had an affecting view. As it was owing to sin, the Compilers of the Catechism, as was most proper, took occasion to introduce a definition of sin in general. But as it was immediately occasioned by a sin, the commission of which was attended with peculiar circumstances, we have, in the answer which I have now repeated, an account of that sin in particular.—Of the manner in which the cruel enemy of mankind attacked the happy pair in paradise, and effected their ruin, the text gives us an explicit, as well as authentic, history. This tragical story I shall review in a cursory manner.
It is proper here, first of all, to take notice of that unhappy being who was the cruel instrument of the ruin of the human species. As to the serpent, of which the inspired Historian speaks, writers have been divided in their sentiments. It has been queried whether a real serpent is intended. One thinks that no such animal was concerned in the matter. According to this hypothesis the seduction of our first parents was effected immediately by Satan, without the instrumentality of any real serpent. When we ask the abettors of this opinion, why the serpent is mentioned at all in the Mosaic history, they tell us, it is because on this occasion Satan signally displayed his subtilty; a quality for which serpents have ever been accounted famous. Another runs into the opposite extreme, affirming that Satan had no concern in the temptation, by which our first parents were ruined. According to this hypothesis, their ruin was effected solely by a material serpent. But the opinion which is commonly received steers a middle course between these two opposite extremes. According to it, Satan was the chief agent, a real serpent the instrument by which he accomplished his purpose. The particular kind and figure of the serpent which he used we know not. Of serpents there are many species. Of the size and the subtilty of many of them extraordinary instances are to be found in history. We read of serpents no less than a hundred and twenty feet long. We have an instance of a serpent of such an enormous size, that, shocking to relate! it swallowed a woman big with child; and of another that swallowed a large buffalo, or wild ox. Serpents have been divided into poisonous and harmless. It is by discharging a particular liquor into the wound made with their teeth, which mixes with the blood, that they do mischief. Mortally was man bitten by the old serpent. Fatal was the wound which he received. Deadly is the poison which it communicated. This poison has diffused itself through the whole human species. This is the mischievous source of death and all our woes.
From the material serpent which the adversary of mankind chose to be the unhappy instrument of their original ruin, and the subtilty which he discovered on this fatal occasion, is he, in the scriptures, denominated a serpent and an old serpent. Rev. xii. 9. and xx. 2. Of the subtilty of the serpent extraordinary things are related in history. As his heart is situated near his head, he is said, in order to his preservation and safety, to wrap up his head in the rest of his body. To the situation of his heart that early intimation which carries in it a rich promise to us, but a fearful threatening against the old serpent, may allude. It, or he, shall bruise thy head; that is thy vital part; and thou shalt bruise his heel. Gen. iii. 15. It is said, that he vomits up his poison when he goes to drink, lest it should go down with the water and hurt him. It is said, that the serpent, called Cerastes, hides himself in the sand, in order that he may bite the horse’s foot, and cause him throw his rider. To this circumstance the Patriarch has been supposed to allude. Dan shall be a serpent by the way, an adder in the path; that biteth the horse-heels, so that his rider shall fall backward. Gen. xlix. 17. It is said, that in order to shut his ears against inchantments, the serpent lays the one close to the ground, and stops the other with his tail. To this the Psalmist has been understood to refer—Their poison is like the poison of a serpent: they are like the deaf adder that stoppeth her ear: which will not hearken to the voice of charmers, charming never so wisely. Psal. lviii. 4, 5.
It has been imagined, from the conversation between the woman and the serpent mentioned in the words of the text, that serpents were at first endued with the faculty of speech. But it certainly was the enemy that spake out of the serpent. It has also been supposed, that serpents then had feet, or rather went on the hinder part of their body, with their head and breast upright. This opinion is evidently taken from what is denounced against the serpent—And the Lord God said unto the serpent, Because thou hast done this, thou art cursed above all cattle, and above every beast of the field: upon thy belly shalt thou go, and dust shalt thou eat all the days of thy life. Gen. iii. 14.
Very different, in appearance and in other respects, are animals of the same species in different parts of the world. Very different from what it is now was the state of the earth, and, we have reason to believe, of its inhabitants both inanimate and irrational, previous to the entrance of sin. The serpent which appeared to Eve, and which the enemy chose to be the instrument of her seduction, is supposed to have been a very beautiful creature; and, on account of its wisdom, or rather craft, a fit tool to be employed in such a work.—Of the address with which the adversary managed the temptation by which he seduced Eve, many writers have taken notice. Innocent and undesigning Eve probably suspected no harm from creatures of any species. She was, perhaps, ignorant of the rebellion that had happened in heaven. The enemy probably made up to her in view of the tree of knowledge, and represented it to her in the most advantageous and engaging light. This seems to be implied in Moses’ words—When the woman saw that the tree was good for food, and that it was pleasant to the eyes, and a tree to be desired to make one wise, she took of the fruit thereof, and did eat. The enemy chose, as has often been observed, to make the attempt when she was alone, and had not access to take the advice of her husband. There is reason also to think, that he allowed her as little time as possible for deliberation.
In the temptation itself there is a manifest gradation, which indicates much of the subtilty of the old serpent. He does not adventure all at once to contradict the divine word; but only with an air of modesty insinuates a suspicion concerning it; and speaks as if he wished to receive information.—For thus he addresses the woman—Yea, hath God said, Ye shall not eat of every tree of the garden? To which the woman replies, We may eat of the fruit of the trees of the garden: but of the fruit of the tree which is in the midst of the garden, God hath said, Ye shall not eat of it, neither shall ye touch it, lest ye die. It has been observed, that she here adds to the divine prohibition; for of touching or not touching that tree, the threatening speaks nothing. It has also been observed, that there seems to be a degree of unbelief in her words. The threatening is most peremptory and express. In the day that thou eatest thereof thou shalt surely die. But her words have been understood to imply uncertainty and doubt. Soon does the enemy advance a step farther, and directly contradicts the threatening—And the serpent said unto the woman, Ye shall not surely die. In order farther to entice her, he reminds her that, notwithstanding her superiority in knowledge, as well as other things, to the irrational creatures, there were other beings superior to her and her husband; and, by eating of the fruit of this tree, they might acquire such knowledge as would render them equal to those angelic beings. For God doth know, says he, that in the day ye eat thereof, then your eyes shall be opened; and ye shall be as gods, knowing good and evil.
It has been imagined, that, in order more effectually to induce the woman to eat of the fruit of this tree, for the acquisition of superior degrees of knowledge, he himself did eat of it, and pretended that in this way he, formerly on a level with the other beasts of his species, had now acquired the faculty of speech and ratiocination, which advanced him to an equality with man. By such machinations and stratagems did the enemy succeed. The woman first and then the man were seduced and ruined. For, says the former, the serpent beguiled me, and I did eat. Of the order in which the seduced pair sinned the Apostle takes particular notice. Adam was first formed, then Eve. And Adam was not deceived, that is, he was not deceived first, or immediately by Satan, but by the woman; the woman being deceived was in the transgression; that is, first in it. 1 Tim. ii. 13, 14.
To a superficial reader this action is apt to appear, if not altogether innocent and harmless, at most but a very frivolous offence. But, upon proper examination, it will be found to be a most aggravated crime, or rather a complication of crimes. It was the mother-sin. What a numerous offspring has it produced! Peculiar circumstances attended it. Let us recollect the person by whom it was committed, and the advantageous circumstances in which he was placed. Highly was he honoured in his creation. Happy was he in both body and mind. A federal relation subsisted between his Maker and him. This honour, so far as we can learn, never has been conferred upon angels. That great and generous being, to whom Adam was indebted for what he was and what he possessed, had, in terms the most express and peremptory, forbidden him to eat of the fruit of this tree. A creature, and a fallen creature, presumes to bid him eat of it. Now the competition was between the great Creator and a most unworthy creature. And, be astonished ye heavens! the creature is preferred to the Creator. The devil is obeyed; God is disobeyed. Ungrateful man!
The criminal act was immediately the transgression of a positive prohibition. This God had chosen to be the particular criterion by which man’s fidelity was to be tried. Different writers have endeavoured to show, however, that it carried in it a virtual violation of all the commandments of the moral law. Let us exemplify this observation. Was it not a violation of the
First Commandment? Does not this precept require an avowal of God, both as the chief good, in the fruition of which only we can be happy; and as our highest Lord, whom we are under every obligation to serve? Were not our first parents duly apprized that, if they ate of the forbidden fruit, they were to forfeit the favour and fruition of God? Did the enjoyment of the all-sufficient God, and a temporary sensual gratification come into competition? Were these two laid in the balance? And did the latter preponderate? The empty creature was preferred to the infinite Creator! Man committed at once two capital evils. He forsook the fountain of living waters; and hewed out to himself broken cisterns that can hold no water. Did God forbid, did the Devil bid, them to eat? Did they in such circumstances actually eat? Was the former disobeyed? the latter obeyed? Was not this a virtual relinquishment of their first and best Master? Was it not a practical acknowledgment of another master? Unhappy exchange!—Was it not a virtual violation of the
Second Commandment? Does not this precept enjoin the observation of all the ordinances and appointments which God is pleased to grant to us? Now, was not abstinence from the fruit of the tree of knowledge one of the appointments of God to our first parents? Such an appointment became the sovereignty of the proprietor of the world. Easy, as well as reasonable, appointment! This appointment, however, our original ancestors did not keep. It has been considered as a transgression of the
Third Precept of the moral law. This commandment, as the Compilers of the Catechism explain it, requires a due acknowledgment and glorification of all the attributes of the Deity. But by eating of the forbidden fruit, man dishonoured different perfections of God. For instance, the veracity of God, interposed in the threatening, was dishonoured. God had, in the most express manner, said, In the day that thou eatest, thou shalt surely die. But, in defiance of the threatening and the divine veracity engaged for the execution of it, our first parents did eat. Was not this act a public affront to the divine Omniscience? Did not man act as if he thought that God did not see him, to call him to an account for this part of his conduct? Was there not atheism, as well as unbelief, in this sin? Accordingly, no sooner did Adam and Eve commit it than they attempted to conceal both themselves and their sin from God. Was not this sin, in a word, a high affront to divine justice? Did not the perpetrators of it, in effect, say, that, notwithstanding the peremptory threatening, God either could not, or at least would not, punish it? This commandment requires the proper observation and use of the word and the works, as well as the attributes, of God? But, by eating of the forbidden fruit, our common parents dishonoured his word; for he had expressly said, But of the tree of the knowledge of good and evil, thou shalt not eat of it, &c. He was dishonoured in his works, as well as in his word; for the fruit of this tree, which was a part of his works, was now used in a manner, and for a purpose diametrically opposite to that for which it was given to man, and he required to use it.—This sin has been considered as a virtual violation of the
Fourth Commandment. That it was committed on the very day on which man was created, and consequently prior to the commencement of the first Sabbath, I do not say, far less will I undertake to prove. Had it been so, it must have been a very bad preparative for the observation of the ensuing day. Was it not incompatible with a due regard to the monitory word which ushers in this commandment, Remember, &c.? Is not this intended to admonish man to endeavour preparation for the Sabbath, previous to its approach; that, when it comes, he may be in some tolerable degree disposed for the sacred exercises of it? But by this sin man was totally incapacitated for the observation of the Sabbath.—Was it not a violation of the
Fifth Precept of the moral law? God now sustained the character of a Father; and Adam stood in the correspondent relation of his son. If the undutiful behaviour of children toward their earthly father be a sin, especially must undutiful behaviour toward the heavenly Father be a most aggravated sin.
Did not Eve fail in her duty to Adam in adventuring to eat of the forbidden fruit in his absence, and without his consent? Was not Adam undutiful to Eve in indulging her in sin, and even concurring with her in it? Were they not both, as our common parents, undutiful and cruel to us all in doing what has been so pernicious and fatal to us, as well as to themselves?—This sin was a gross violation of the
Sixth Commandment. Every sin has a murderous tendency. Every sinner God bespeaks thus—O sinner! thou hast destroyed thyself. Shocking is every species of self-murder. Every sinner, however, is a self-murderer. Our first parents, by one fatal act, murdered themselves, and the countless millions of mankind born and to be born. Such another massacre, in respect of the number of the murdered, never has been perpetrated by human hands. Not only the bodies, but the souls, no less than the bodies, of all mankind were murdered. Universal, as well as fatal catastrophe!—This sin has been considered as a virtual violation of the
Seventh Precept of the moral law. On account of it our first parents were deprived of that external lustre which attended their bodies during the innocent state; and which, probably, was intended to guard them against such irregular desires toward one another, as are inconsistent with that purity in thought, speech, and behaviour, which this precept of the holy law enjoins. How their modesty was hurt by this criminal act the history of it and its consequences informs us. The eyes of them both were opened, and they knew that they were naked; and they sewed fig-leaves together, and made themselves aprons. That it has been the unhappy source of numberless gross violations of this precept is well known.—Was it not a palpable breach of the
Eighth Commandment? The tree of knowledge God had reserved to himself. Man could not reckon it his own as he could the other trees of paradise. If, therefore, he intermeddled with it, was he not guilty of sacrilegious robbery? Did he not rob himself, as well as God? Along with life itself, he forfeited the riches, the honours, and the comforts of it.—Was it not a virtual transgression of the
Ninth Precept of the moral law? Is the violation of truth between man and man a sin? Is a man of veracity and honour, when we give him the lie, affronted? Had God interposed his veracity in the threatening; pledging his honour for the execution of it? Did man after all adventure to contradict it? Was not this in effect to make the God of truth a liar? Did not God threaten most severely to punish this sin? Was not the commission of it, therefore, after such warnings and threatenings, the grossest insult to truth?—This sin was also a notorious breach of the
Tenth Commandment. The forbidden tree was the only thing in paradise, nay, in the world itself, which God had withheld from man. He had the richest variety and plenty; a profusion of the comforts, as well as the necessaries of life. Had he the disposal and use of the fowls of the air, of the fishes of the sea, and of the numerous beasts and various fruits of the earth, one tree only excepted? and was he not contented? One thing only was withheld from him, and this one thing he coveted!
Thus the sin, whereby our first parents fell from the estate wherein they were created, was far from being a small offence. It was, on the contrary, an enormous evil, and was attended with a variety of the most aggravating circumstances. He that committed it was under special obligations to God. It was committed in paradise. Sin having previously entered the celestial paradise, now had insinuated itself into the terrestrial. Almost as soon as man was created did he grievously offend his Creator. Almost as soon as he had the honour of covenanting with his Maker, notwithstanding the flattering prospects which he had, he violated the covenant. Was he not now guilty of the basest ingratitude to his most bountiful benefactor? Was not this sin the most criminal and shameful disobedience? The most abandoned and infamous of the creatures was obeyed; the great God disobeyed. Was it not the most unnatural and unprovoked rebellion? The rightful proprietor of all worlds was man’s rightful sovereign. Had not man solemnly promised fealty and allegiance to him?—From what hath been said we may infer
(1.) How ready we are to be mistaken about sin. How many call darkness light, and light darkness! Were our innocent parents deceived? No wonder though we be deceived. Of the deceitfulness of sin, the Apostle speaks, Heb. iii. 13. Of the strength of it he speaks on another occasion. Is it strong? and is it deceitful? A formidable enemy must it be. If upright Adam fell before it, no wonder though we fall. Our most dangerous enemy is within us.—For the human heart is deceitful above all things, and desperately wicked.
(2.) We see whence the evil, as well as the danger, of sin arises. Is the thing, in itself innocent, forbidden? Does it seem harmless? It cannot, however, be either innocent or harmless. What the law forbids we must forbear. It is our interest, as well as our duty, to do so. For, if we either omit duty or commit sin, God is offended; and the offence shall not pass with impunity. He will by no means clear the guilty.
(3.) What an aggravated condemnation and punishment have we all incurred! If Adam’s first sin had such a complication of evils in it, how guilty must we all be from our earliest infancy! What a complicated and aggravated sin is imputed to us from the earliest moments of our existence! If there is so much evil in one sin, what must the demerit and the punishment of our innumerable and aggravated iniquities be!
(4.) How dangerous must it be to parley with the tempter or with his temptations! He may assume the form of a friend; but he is our determined foe. Friendship he may profess; but the most unrelenting enmity lurks in his heart. What specious professions did he make to our first mother! In the snare which he spread for her was she caught. If he deceived her, notwithstanding her innocence and her knowledge, no wonder though he deceive us. Deceiving he destroys souls. How necessary then the Apostle’s caution! Be sober, be vigilent; because your adversary the devil, as a roaring lion, walketh about, seeking whom he may devour. 1 Pet. v. 8. Watch and pray, says our Lord, that ye enter not into temptation.
In fine, Great, precious, must be the salvation of which Jesus is the Author. Great is the evil of sin; great the danger to which it exposes us. Is sin so great a evil? Does it expose to so great a punishment? Is a salvation, in all respects great, provided for us? Is it fully and freely offered to us? Let us take heed what reception we give to it. How shall we escape if we neglect so great a salvation? In manifold respects is this salvation great. Great is the Saviour himself, and great is his salvation. From the greatest sins does he save. Great is the number he saves. Great is the glory that accrues to God from this salvation. With what alacrity, and how gratefully, should we accept of such a Saviour and such a salvation! Have we all been bitten, mortally wounded, by the old serpent? A sovereign Physician and Healer is provided. An expedient, in all respects, worthy of the wisdom as well as of the grace of God, has been found out. How unexpected was the method which Moses was directed to use for healing the Israelites bitten by the fiery serpents in the wilderness? Fit emblem of the still more surprising expedient which Heaven has invented, and uses, for the salvation of our sinful world! Into the mysteries of redeeming love and wisdom angels desire to look. With incessant wonder, and endless joy, do they pry into these things. Have fallen angels been permitted to perish? Are fallen men pitied? Is a salvation purchased by blood, blood divine, now offered to you? See then, I say, again, see that you do not neglect it. May he that has the human heart in his hand determine us all to accept of it! Amen.